Welcome to situational coaching and how the Patriots ignored the teaching of their own HC.
It's interesting how you mentioned the lack of red zone chances as the reason why the TE's weren't involved in the pass game.
The Colts D saw those 4th qtr possessions by the Patriots as red zone football, they needed to stop the Pats from going 10 yds and getting a 1st down and that's exactly how they played it.
They compressed their D at the line to stuff the run and went man to man with their D smurfs DB's on our O smurf WR's.
And guess what??
The Patriots NEVER adjusted to what the Colts were doing on defense in those possessions.
The Colts are jamming the line, playing man on our small WR's and we don't need a 6' 6" TE in our pass game at that point??
Are you kidding me?
If there were ever a time in that game that screamed out for those big tall pass catching TE's it was in those 4th qtr possessions when the Colts D was in a red zone mode and the Pats did nothing to counter it/exploit it.
Situational football and Bill O'Brien and this O flunked and flunked badly in the 4th qtr.
Thankfully Peyton Manning bailed them out with a terrible INT.
It NEVER should have come to that
And you know who agrees with me?? Tom Brady.