- Joined
- Apr 4, 2013
- Messages
- 10,333
- Reaction score
- 11,179
Face it, there are very few QBs that consistently give you great play in the NFL. There are many who may give you great play for a game or a season, but not year after year. Except TB12.No one loves Hoyer, and success with Cassel looked like missing the playoffs with an easy schedule and the greatest offense of all-time.
Generally speaking you need great quarterback play to win in the NFL. Cassels and Hoyers, as we've seen on every team that tried to use them as starters after they left the Patriots, ain't gonna get you ****.
There are a whole bunch of reasons for that. Coaching must be a big one. O line play must be another. Overall team quality, WRs etc another.
So I think it’s unrealistic to evaluate QBs purely on their W/L stats with other teams. How would Cassel and Hoyer have looked as starters for the Pats? Having Belichick coaching them, playing behind an O line coached by Dante?
Also keep in mind that Brady has five seasons with records of 11-5 or worse, and made the playoffs four out of those five seasons. So Cassel not making the playoffs is not as much his fault as it is simple bad luck.