QB rankings according to coaches, executives and scouts

[sb1]

 

[Ring 6]

I really want to see Maye when he has time to throw - which didn't seem to be much of the time last year. Anything in the 6-10 range right now is great for him. Takes a couple of years to really prove it beyond that.

He was the best 10+ downfield passer in the nfl last year

 

[Sect140]

Lmao. That is all.

And he wonders why Pats fans hate him.

 

[Diffs4]

Lmao. That is all.

The Mike Felger model is way too prevalent in 2026. Just like Felger does not believe half the **** he says, there is no way Simms believes this. But it generates a lot of clicks and attention and that is all they care about. It makes me appreciate Reiss that he has not gone down this path even though it has probably cost him money and attention.

 

[Ice_Ice_Brady]

It’s fair to question if Mahomes is a top three quarterback. He isn’t coming off a bad statistical year. He’s coming off a bad statistical year where he went six and nine. If this is based on where QBs are right now, he does not really have the same fallback in the past when you could always say he won 13 games and was fire with the game on the line.

That said, I still think he’s top five but time will tell.

 

[captain stone]

Herbert? Really? 0 - 3 in the playoffs? Never won a playoff game. Herbert should be #5? One of the biggest playoff chokers ever? ************.

Not all of the factors in those 3 losses were his fault.

 

[TommyD4207]

Not all of the factors in those 3 losses were his fault.

He didn't help. He was terrible in Foxboro this year, only gets off the hook because cj Stroud was worse

 

[Ring 6]

Not all of the factors in those 3 losses were his fault.

No but none of the reasons they won were him.
Sports in the social media age has created a dynamic where if you fail
and have an excuse people call you better than the guy who succeeded, which he also did by overcoming excuses.