QB rankings according to coaches, executives and scouts

[sb1]

I think a year ago all of us would have signed up for Maye to be #8 and there's no reason to think he's hit his ceiling already. Could also make an argument that this is too low.

Kermit Mahomes is #2 on reputation only and nothing more. He stunk last year and the refs weren't helping him anymore.

 

[KCSVEN]

I think a year ago all of us would have signed up for Maye to be #8 and there's no reason to think he's hit his ceiling already. Could also make an argument that this is too low.

Kermit Mahomes is #2 on reputation only and nothing more. He stunk last year and the refs weren't helping him anymore.

Yeah, look at Mahomes stats, advanced or otherwise, the last 3 years and someone tell me how he's a top 2 NFL QB?
Maye would be in the top 3 if it wasn't just 1 year, he has another year like last year and he'll be in the top 3.

If you limit the list to those that will be under 30 when the 2027 Super Bowl is played:
Herbert: 28
Maye: 24
Williams: 25

 

[Thelonious]

Dak Prescott? Number 6? Every so often he'll have a game or a brief stretch of games which serve to keep delusions of his excellence alive and his bank account pleasingly plump. I guess it's working for him, on both fronts.

As for Drake, #7 with a bullet based on abundant upside is probably about right. He has more to prove, but I really think he'll succeed in doing so. I expect him to jump to top-five by this time next year.

 

[PatsFan2]

I think a year ago all of us would have signed up for Maye to be #8 and there's no reason to think he's hit his ceiling already. Could also make an argument that this is too low.

Kermit Mahomes is #2 on reputation only and nothing more. He stunk last year and the refs weren't helping him anymore.

Kermit have three SB rings and played in Five SB's unlike his overrated peers.

 

[DoubleDeluxe]

Kermit have three SB rings and played in Five SB's unlike his overrated peers.

Funny how some of us Pats fans forget.
Back in the day when Brady was winning his first SBs without gaudy stats, and Manning was rewriting history books, we all rightly pointed out how Brady was a winner, and that’s all that mattered.
Now probably many of those same people want to pretend Mahomes isn’t a top 3 NFL QB.
I am not a Patrick fan, but dude is a proven winner and I have no doubt he will continue to be a winner for many more years.
Maye is ranked in about the right spot, but has the ceiling to climb much higher on the list.

 

[PatsFan2]

Funny how some of us Pats fans forget.
Back in the day when Brady was winning his first SBs without gaudy stats, and Manning was rewriting history books, we all rightly pointed out how Brady was a winner, and that’s all that mattered.
Now probably many of those same people want to pretend Mahomes isn’t a top 3 NFL QB.
I am not a Patrick fan, but dude is a proven winner and I have no doubt he will continue to be a winner for many more years.
Maye is ranked in about the right spot, but has the ceiling to climb much higher on the list.

Couldn't have said it any better myself: I don't get the hate for Mahomes on here. But to each their own as they say. The same people who dump on Mahomes have their collective heads up Josh Allen *yet to play in a SB* and Joe Burrow's *always injured* @ss: I guess they're more likable.

 

[PatsFan2]

I would take Trevor Lawrence our Prescott - Herbert and Goff *thank you*. Also Jayden Daniels had too great a Rookie year to be discarded. Glad Caleb Williams is proving his Patsfans doubters RONG!

 

[Vindicate]

Dak consistently has very good regular season stats only to flare out when it matters the most. Decent fantasy option and literally nothing more.

Herbert? By all means out up great numbers his first two years but also had a stacked offense. Has also looked rough when the lights are most bright.

I feel those are the two he's already ahead of, and Jackson/Burrow aren't as far ahead as some might think.