Sometimes the job of the #1 is to take up all the oxygen in the room. Not saying he was doubled every play but he certainly wasn't left on an island. And hand it to our D for playing sensational against him.
The idea we don't need a #1 is a Brady mindset imo. We need to play with the expectation Maye can't make magic out of beans vs top talent in the playoffs, cause he had a hard time. And it wasn't just the o line. Too often windows were too tight or he had to search too hard to find a guy. It is easy to say find the open WR when you aren't the guy who needs to do it. When you have a #1 it simplifies your reads. That is just as important as any other part that shows up in a stat sheet, particularly if you aren't a Brady or close to prime Mahomes behind a crazy good oline, a great scheme/play all and personnel designed to create space to make your life easier.
I am tired of the idea we are above needing that kind of player, particularly after that offensive playoff run we just had. Clearly the fide if the ball needs to be addressed massively. And even when mate had time it didn't look great. So let's make things easier on him.