I'm wondering what it is about Gaffney that makes you say he's not a prototypical #2? His speed? Ability to go deep perhaps? As you said he's an excellent slot receiver and seems to run routes well.
If Jackson can offer more than Gaffney and earns his starting spot, given Jackson's attributes, how do you see affecting our offense? Do you think it might actually improve or become more dominant over last year?
Speed. Size. Playing style.
As far as the offense, of course. I've been high on Jackson since he was drafted. As I said in the 2007 offseason when Moss, Stallworth, Welker, Washington, and Brady came along, 2008 would be the year when Jackson and Thomas would shine. Well, judging by the fact that Thomas will have to suck badly to lose the #2 spot that has been essentially given to him, and the fact that they have not replaced Stallworth on the roster, it's obvious that they really are looking for Jackson and Thomas to live up to their draft status and begin the era of their effectiveness in this offense.
We all know about Jackson's talents, but we also heard about some potential attitude problems, and then of course the injuries. I think the Jackson is really looking to capitalize on this opportunity that the Pats are giving him to develop into a premier NFL receiver across from Moss. The chemistry between Gaffney and Brady is undeniable, but chances are you'll still be seeing a lot of spread formations from the Pats this season, even with more of Maroney's and Morris' ground game than we saw last year. But Gaff right now is a veteran backup plan to the offensive presence Jackson is expected by the Pats to be.
My feeling is that, come November when Moss, Jackson, and Welker are comfortably installed as the productive top-3 that they're capable of being, the love affair that PatsFans seems to have with Gaffney will hopefully end. Again, I'm not saying that I don't like Gaffney (I've been accused as such for giving Caldwell the edge over him coming off the 2006 season), but by June and July, Belichick and the Pats have a pretty good idea of what each player's role is going to be on the team. Training camp will certainly refine that, but seeing Jackson out there opposite Moss in minicamp, seeing him perform, and hearing him talk about the opportunity that he was given means something.