Maye didn’t just decide to be a QB. He shows such skills that the patriots drafted him with a top 5 pick. There is no minor league. You can’t play him
against bad players to warm up.
If you really believe that by playing football and learning on the job he would suffer mental incapacity and be ruined for life, then we kicked the wrong guy.
I am fully aware that if you wait a year to play him he will be a little better than he would be if you played him today. But if you play him today he will be a lot better next year than if you don’t.
If you are invested in winning this year, it may not be best to play him. But this team is clearly not invested in winning this year.
So the number 1 goal of this year should be to get Maye as much progress as humanly possible. Every snap in every game and every rep with the 1s in practice gets him experience and progresses his development.
If you are right and he plays and has difficulty and that causes him to go into a shell and ruins him, then he isn’t the guy and we found out a year sooner.
What you are suggesting is that we drafted a guy whose success will predominately depend on his ability to work under intensely difficult circumstances, face enormous pressure, and make a living overcoming adversity and we should be afraid to expose him to any of that because it could ruin him. If it ruins him today it will ruin him at whatever point you expose him to it.