Argument to end all arguments? ( Manning vs. Brady )

[justinb]

Since media people and former players wont make a decision on who is better, Manning vs. Brady. And since most would agree that between, Leadership, accuracy, 2-minute drills, dependability, etc.. pretty much lay even.

how bout "Who makes fewer mistakes"?

Does Brady or Manning make fewer mistakes? ( can this even be measured ? )

 

[Pat the Pats Fan]

Since media people and former players wont make a decision on who is better, Manning vs. Brady. And since most would agree that between, Leadership, accuracy, 2-minute drills, dependability, etc.. pretty much lay even.

how bout "Who makes fewer mistakes"?

Does Brady or Manning make fewer mistakes? ( can this even be measured ? )

What are mistakes? Fumbles, are mistakes, but they usually are due to external sources. Picks, OK, bad pass, but what about tipped balls, is that the QBs fault, technically no. Penalties, maybe, like delay, but if it was planned, that can't be considered either. So my take, no, they are / can all be subjective in nature and will result in more debate than a clear answer.

 

[Fixit]

Since media people and former players wont make a decision on who is better, Manning vs. Brady. And since most would agree that between, Leadership, accuracy, 2-minute drills, dependability, etc.. pretty much lay even.

how bout "Who makes fewer mistakes"?

Does Brady or Manning make fewer mistakes? ( can this even be measured ? )

I will never, ever put Manning in the same breath as Brady with regards to leadership. Manning's a great QB, yes, but his leadership is crap. He's thrown his O-line under the bus on more than one occasion, he points fingers on the field, and when he's losing or makes a crucial mistake he gets this defeated "woe is me" body language that deflates the whole team.

These are all things you've never seen or heard from Brady.

This is not even up for debate.