There was a kicker in the early 90's I think his last name was Garcia, Teddy Garcia? He was the worst, I think it might have been after they canned him that they held open tryouts for the position.
We have a winner. I realize he was only the kicker, but get this, he was 6-13 on FG's and 11-16 on XP's. Half of the posters here can go 11-16 on XP's. For real players, I thought Chris Canty was as bad as anyone and Jimmy "15yd cushion on 3rd and 5" Hitchcocck had some rough times.