NFLN Top 100 players :10 to 1

[SVN]

Anyone watching

#10 **** butkus
#9 Don hutson
#8 Peyton manning..

 

[JustEndTheSeason]

Did they mention Manning's pic? I hope so!

 

[patsinthesnow]

 

[JGaffney]

So...Manning is 8 because of regular season records..oh no, wait, Brady has the best season in history.
Well, must be rings - oh wait.
Must have been the lack of talent around him...oh, wait.
Must be his performance in the clutch...oh wait, can't be that.
Must be...?

MVPs? Seriously, he won more popularity contests than anyone in history and that puts him #8 to Brady's 21? WTF?

 

[SVN]

i dont have an issue manning > brady. its a poll of 85 people giving ratings to each player out of 10. iam just surprised he is that high and that much higher than brady.
brady's stock went down just because pats won 11 games without him and with cassel i think

 

[SHOWTIME15]

i dont have an issue manning > brady. its a poll of 85 people giving ratings to each player out of 10. iam just surprised he is that high and that much higher than brady.
brady's stock went down just because pats won 11 games without him and with cassel i think

that and the fact that brady hasn't been able to repeat his 2007 performance and never will.

 

[VectorPrime]

that and the fact that brady hasn't been able to repeat his 2007 performance and never will.

They don't seem to care that Manning will never repeat his 2004 performance (49 TDS)

 

[JustEndTheSeason]

that and the fact that brady hasn't been able to repeat his 2007 performance and never will.

I can't imagine anyone, not just Tom, repeating that sort of season.

 

[ausbacker]

As long as Brady continues his greatness in the post-season and wins a few more rings I don't care if they put Manning at number 1 and Brady at 2.

Common sense versus applied opinion.

 

[ALP]

loL

guys, dont try to rationalize it, this ranking difference between the two, and ALSO the fact that they have manning>brady makes absolutely no sense

u cant rationalize stupidity, and thats the only thing this ranking represents

(i dont know the rankings of montana and marino, but so long as they have montana above marino, there is no argument to not have brady above manning, plain and simple)

 

[PatriotsInGA]

#4 - Montana

Understandable, he's number one on my list so I can't think of a player better than him.

 

[CheeseMonkeys]

Manning is the best Passer in the NFL and Brady is the Best QB. I can't remember who said it, but that is pretty much the case. Both are great leaders and very smart at the position. Give it another 5 years and Brady will be top 10, should be ranked higher than Manning at that time.

 

[SVN]

everything they say about montana can be said about brady i think except that brady lost a SB

 

[TheGreatestEVER]

I love how the moment Dallas Clark is out for the season, everybody in the media starts gushing about how he is so great for winning games with nooooooo offensive talent, but wait he still has Reggie Wayne and Pierre G. Who the hell played with Brady up until 07, NO ONE! I could careless about the ranking, just the superbowls

 

[VectorPrime]

everything they say about montana can be said about brady i think except that brady lost a SB

Yeah well, when Brady gets his 4th then 4/5 is better than 4/4.

 

[SVN]

that and the fact that brady hasn't been able to repeat his 2007 performance and never will.

not sure its about that , marino and manning couldnt repeat too. Its about MVPS and Its the patriots team thing and the huge factor is belichick which has hurt brady. they cant envision brady being sucessful without belichick. Add the fact that the patriots are generally disliked by the voters esp after spygate which has effected this iam sure.

 

[CheeseMonkeys]

If we had just played slightly better back in the 07 Superbowl... Just SLIGHTLY better, does anyone think Brady would be in the top 10? That couple points probably would have made the difference of 11 spots, ain't that sad?

 

[SVN]

the parcells dungy exchange was funny

 

[VectorPrime]

If we had just played slightly better back in the 07 Superbowl... Just SLIGHTLY better, does anyone think Brady would be in the top 10? That couple points probably would have made the difference of 11 spots, ain't that sad?

The player rankings is one of the least important reasons why I wish to god we scored 4 mores points but yeah, probably.

 

[reflexblue]

So...Manning is 8 because of regular season records..oh no, wait, Brady has the best season in history.
Well, must be rings - oh wait.
Must have been the lack of talent around him...oh, wait.
Must be his performance in the clutch...oh wait, can't be that.
Must be...?

MVPs? Seriously, he won more popularity contests than anyone in history and that puts him #8 to Brady's 21? WTF?

Its the commercials.