JJDChE
In the Starting Line-Up
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2004
- Messages
- 2,488
- Reaction score
- 534
Jackie Smith retired 9 years before Winslow with more receiving yards than Winslow. It points more to how the hall clusters guys together and will put in the player who's been waiting long unless a player comes along who's a clear first ballot player. Andre Reed just went in this year after waiting a long time. Is he a better player than Marvin Harrison or Isaac Bruce?
The only guys who are going in first ballot are the guys who had both a high peak and longevity. One or the other gets you the waiting list. Shannon Sharpe who had both plus championships he played a big role in didn't go first ballot.
I'm not saying I agree. At his peak Gronk's the GOAT. But the voters history says he would wait. Hell Borges won't even advocate for him out of spite as the local representative.
I guess if he did end his career today he'd be in a logjam with Witten and Gates.
Personally, I've never been that impressed with Witten. I mean, the volume is impressive, I was just never impressed with the eye test. Gates, OTOH, blew me away at times. Same with Gronk. Witten is definitely in on longevity and volume, but he wasn't as impressive of a player, to me, as Gonzalez, Gates and Gronk.