I mean how can you hate a guy who is smart enough to give a TED talk. I WANT these kinds of guys on my team. And I think that part of the genius that is BB is that he wants them too...and can deal with them because he is as smart as they are and isn't intimidated by their "differentness".
The key quote here is from Reiss' story, "I caught 90 balls, and lost a ton of games, and its not much fun".
Now as for his future, clearly the Pats can't afford to pay him what he's worth as an elite, full service, starting TE. So normally you'd say he's gone. It was nice to have him here, but you can't keep everyone. BUT, this guy is clearly NOT everyone. Staying here for a lot less (say in the 5-6MM range, when he could get $8MM elsewhere) might still be the best thing for him BECAUSE he's a lot more than just a TE.
By staying here be become associated with winning. He can finish his career on a good team, in a great environment, that appreciates his skills as well as his personality. Then there are the financial benefits, especially for a "creative type" who animates, makes movies, writes books, etc. Knowing guys like Kraft, Brady, Mark Wahlberg, Damen, etc could open doors and generate investments that would be FAR more valuable to him long term, than the 2 or 3 Million in salary for a few years he could get elsewhere before the game beats you up and spits you out.
I only say this BECAUSE, Marty is a different sort of guy than most guys. He's a guy who ACTUALLY has options beyond football and a future in the media.
BTW- Great OP, but bad title. Weird is definitely NOT a word I'd use to describe Marty Bennett...far from it.