Sure they were better than McCarver, but they were still pretty bad. Its one thing to be unbiased, its another thing to be completely uninformed.
Making note of the temporary seats on the green monster that the Red Sox put up for the playoffs. Stupid gaffs like complementing Becketts "fastball to strikeout ratio", or calling a groundball to Pedroia a double-play ball despite there being 2 outs. They went for what seemed like at bats at a time without saying a word, but whenever they did they frequently said something stupid.
Although not listening to Remy talk about his website/books/commercials/restaurant was very refreshing. As was not hearing Orsillo giggle every 10 minutes.