I personally saw him play for the Patriots in 1960 and thought him to have an above average arm. He could really sling the ball and as memory serves me, he was relatively accurate. Songin teamed up with Jimmy Colclough, another B.C. grad, to make an exciting QB/WR tandem in those early days. Here are a few facts about Butch which you may find interesting.
While in college, along with being the starting QB in football, he was an All-American defenseman for the BC Eagles ice hockey team and a member of the 1948–1949 national championship team.
Butch was selected 247th in the NFL 1950 draft by the Cleveland Browns.
A knee injury suffered in a college all-star game stalled his early professional football aspirations.
Because the early days of his football career were spent playing for semi-pro teams, by the time he signed on to be the Boston Patriots first QB in 1960, he was 36 years old.
While playing QB for the Boston Patriots, he was simultaneously coaching the football team at Marian High in Framingham as well as the high school hockey team in the off season.
Butch played two seasons for the Patriots followed by one season for the New York Titans, (yet to become the Jets.)
From 1953 to 1954, Songin played for the Hamilton Tiger-Cats of the Interprovincial Rugby Football Union, predecessor of the Canadian Football League. He won the Grey Cup in his rookie season in 1953.