they did something similar on ESPN radio on XM. 52% thought manning was better. the host also thought manning was better and that Brady had benefited all this time because of a great defense, a dominating defense that the manning never had. i thought this was funny because they never mention about how Brady basically had 2nd tier recievers almost his whole career while Manning has had elite type reciever most of his. that being said i would think that Brady and his 3 SB rings with a decent recieving corp would trump mannings 1 ring with an elite recieving corp. just my 2 cents.