As per NFL Prime Time: Luck will eventually be better than Peyton was @Indy

[thenepatsrule]

WTF............ a last minute victory against the horrible lions and ESPN makes such a bold prediction? Lets not forget why the Colts were behind, Luck had thrown 3 INTS ...... I agree he has 5 4th Q comebacks, but predicting that he will be better than Peyton?

talk about "prisoner of the moment"

 

[fnordcircle]

While I agree, he does look better during his rookie season than Peyton did during his.

Granted, Peyton wasn't throwing to Reggie Wayne he was throwing to Jermoe Pathon or whatever his name was, but Peyton took 2-3 years to come into his own Luck seems well ahead of that.

Personally I think Luck's ceiling is much lower than Peyton's.

 

[PatriotSeven]

He can because Peyton is overrated and chokes in the playoffs. His bar should be Brady. And he's smart, which is why he's wearing #12

Luck has a chance of getting more than 1 ring.

 

[DocHoliday]

What an insult to one of the all time greats.

 

[ALP]

that statement is beyond ridiculous

you cannot make a statement like that about a guy after 3 SEASONS, let alone 10 or so games

 

[Rusty Coupe]

As the Jets found out with Skid-Mark, it is how much does the QB progresses after his first season that is most telling. Luck leads the NFL with 16 int, and his completion % is near the bottom at 55%, Wilson and RGIII may end up being better QB.

2012 NFL Player Passing Stats - National Football League - ESPN

I'm not saying Luck isn't a good QB(he is), just not ready to put him in the HOF