Wozzy
Pro Bowl Player
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2018
- Messages
- 14,020
- Reaction score
- 20,134
You grade prospects the same no matter what. If Tet is a B+ or B- based on your evaluation system... you don't reach for him in the first. It doesn't matter how desperate you are for the WR position or the year. If the draft was this crappy, you should have signed more free agent WR's.I’m with you most of the time on it being a team game not a god QB, and Oline over shiny hood ornaments but judging a draft based on every other rookie in history is a crazy take. You can only draft who is available and just because Campbell would have been the 4th OT taken last year doesn’t change he is the consensus #1 this year. You admit to having not evaluated the class yet so listen to those who have. Every single player likely to be available at #4 has a question mark, a flaw, a potential reason they will bust. There are exactly 2 “A+” players and a QB that’s going to be drafted top 5 on hopes, prayers, and sadly no one better.
That leaves the Patriots in the unenviable position of getting first choice in a tier of players that are all equally questionable. Some don’t care about Tet’s lack of speed and consistent production, others like myself call it a deal breaker and wouldn’t draft him in the top 12. For some 4 years of elite production against the best the country offers outweighs Campbell’s holy crap historic small wingspan. Why draft an 8/10 RB when there are about (20) 7/10 RBs further down in the draft? Graham has some great stats and athletic ability but came in 30 lbs underweight, plus played next to a behemoth monster so how good will he be really? My personal favorite, after having watched tape, is a 20 year old dancing bear with feet that made me say wow multiple times, not to mention several nasty pancake blocks. Problem is Membou has only ever played RT. Can he make the switch? 20 is pretty young so that’s a gamble I am willing to take but plenty of players are one side only, wiping your ass with your left hand and all that.
Point is saying “there is always an A+ player at #4, just maybe not at a position of need” is not true this year. The Patriots just have first choice in a tier of question marks.
Otherwise there's probably WR's available in the 2nd and 3rd round with a similar grade to Tet. I had no problem with Polk as a prospect, I had the same grade on him as I had on Javon Baker... they both should have been taken in the 4th round or later. Polk shouldn't have been taken in the 2nd round... that was a reach.
I don't have to listen to those who have been looking at the draft class to judge Tet, he's done working out from what I can see. The combine and pro day came and went and he chickened out.
Ask me in April for a fuller evaluation of the draft class, it's too soon... but Tet is overrated.












