Freeney can't stop the run. He's a one trick pony. Is it any wonder that he couldn't get his asking price? People in the league know what he's about by now. His trick is valuable, but how often can he accomplish it as he gets on in years?
2010 10 sacks
2011 8.5 sacks
2012 5.0 sacks
I see a pattern in Freeney's production here and it's a downward trend.
But this is the NFL and to assume all 2 year trends will continue indefinitely is not a sound theory.
Freeney is EXACTLY what this defense needs. He can play 60-70% of the snaps by playing:
3rd down
2nd and long
1st down and 2nd vs pass happy teams
2 minute D
When we have a lead and the other team is one dimensional
What he brings is a guy that draws the attention of the offense, forces them to account for him and often double him, and the ability to exert pressure that shortens the pass play whether he gets to the QB or not.
Freeney has affected more pass plays (by sacks, hits that throw off the pass, pressure that causes the pass play to be shorter, or attention that freed a teammate up to do the same) than any player in the NFL since LT.
This also creates more opportunities for other players. This also allows us to blitz more because we have players with individual rush skills that can take advantage of what the blitz creates. (last year too often we couldn't afford to blitz because we had no one--or not enough--who could beat the one on one that was created by it, so we would just end up covering with less)
Yes he is poor vs the run, but with one run liability on the field but intense pressure in 2 minute defense, we would have at least 2 more rings.
Abraham would be fine too, but the one thing that would help this defense the most is exactly what Freeney brings.
Disclaimer: This comes from a guy who thinks Freeney is one of the most overreated players of the last 10 years because of his weaknesses, but his strengths are exactly what we need, and his weaknesses would be minimized here.