Brady and Manning occupy #'s 1 & 2. What remaining 3 QB's in your opinion rank above him?
Thats something I would like to know. I guess Palmer and Favre could still be rated higher but out of all of the guys that were rated higher in the preseason I think he has surpassed almost all of them. Could anyone really say that they would rather have Drew Brees or John Kitna over Ben? because I sure couln't. Hasselbeck could be a solid candidate, but Hasselbeck isn't an elite QB imo, he is a solid productive quarterback who fits in well with his team. Tony Romo? I dont think so, he hasn't proven himself enough yet, besides do any of those guys have superbowl rings? nope, has Palmer,Kitna,Brees, or Hasselbeck singlehandedly led their team to the superbowl? Hasselbeck got there, but that was probably thanks to the MVP year from Shaun Alexander. My top ten qb list would have to look something like this:
1.)Brady-everyone knows why
2.)Manning-One of the smartest QB's to ever play the game
3.)Palmer-He's having a down year, but as long as thats all it is, he is an awesome passer.
4.)Roethlisberger-He has all of the tools, he just has a little bit of maturing to do.
5.)Favre-He is still getting it done at 38, besides hes Brett Favre
6.)Hasselbeck-He has been a solid franchise QB for the hawks for along time.
7.)Romo-He's looked good so far, lets see if it continues
8.)Mcnabb-When 100% he is one of the best, problem is, when is he 100%
9.)Derek Anderson-he's been a surprise and the browns are a winning team. who would have known?
10.)Bulger-A fine passer, hes just too unreliable.