PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans

Kamerion Wimbley... A Mirage?

Status
Not open for further replies.

PonyExpress

In the Starting Line-Up
Joined
Feb 12, 2006
Messages
4,659
Reaction score
78
When people have discussed “Work-out Wonders†Wimbley has escaped scrutiny. Lawson has been mentioned, but Lawson was highly productive over a two year period in college. Also, contrary to the popular belief, watching NCState you will see that Mario Williams was not regularly double teamed. Some have tried to discredit Lawson’s production by saying it was a byproduct of the heavy attention paid to Williams. I don’t see it that way at all. Lawson’s production was genuine. I would say McCargo, the DT, was the beneficiary of both Lawson and Williams and is quickly becoming one of the most overrated players in the draft.
But getting back to Wimbley, if you had never laid eyes on him you would say he is a marginal prospect. Poor against the pass compared with his draftable peers, marginal production against the run over the past two years, and lacking in durability. Yet, after the offseason process, he suddenly is a top-12 pick. People claim he is this year’s Demarcus Ware. First of all, that comparison is faulty because Wimbley isn’t the athlete Ware was. For example, Ware (6’4’’ 251) had 27 reps, ran a 4.56 40, had a 4.08 short shuttle, a 10.93 long shuttle, and a 6.83 3-cone drill, Wimbley (6’4’’ 248) had 24 reps, ran a 4.61 40, 4.49 short shuttle, an 11.80 long shuttle, and a 6.97 3-cone drill. The agility drills set them apart by a wide margin. So what is it about Wimbley that has drawn so much attention? My conclusion is that he is your classic “looks like Tarzan†case. There is no denying the cat looks like Tarzan in shorts. He is a certifiable beast. And he did well at the senior bowl. But so did Gabe Watson… where is the production? Wimbley showed up in the Miami game to open the season, and pretty much disappeared until the VT game in the ACC championship, where he had some good contain on Marcus Vick. To me, this says he turns it on when the TV cameras are on, and goes through the motions the rest of the time.
I wouldn’t be surprised at all if Wimbley is a stalking horse. Sounds conspiratorial, but Wimbley’s surge to the top of the charts is hard to justify. If the Pats take him at #21, as Pro Football Weekly suggests, I will be shocked.
 
Wimbley was a mirage in the Senior Bowl alright, blowing by lead-foot RTs and being easily handled by a TE rated barely adequate in blocking skills.
 
Wimbley has decent production in his Sr year. His ESPN profile also mentions that he missed significant time this year due to injuries. One thing I remember is how that guy on the NFL network was praising Wimbley's form in the pass-rushing drill during the combine.

I think he's one of those hard-to-judge prospects BB was talking about becuase of his limited playing time. I guess his pass-rushing ability is hard to overlook though. He could be a John Abraham type of player. I agree with you though that Lawson is a better prospect based on production.
 
To be honest I made a mistake in my analysis of Wimbley. I said he had good contain on Marcus Vick of VT in the ACC championship. I meant good contain against Michael Robinson of PSU in the Fiesta Bowl. I believe Wimbley missed the ACC championship with an injury. So I screwed up- just letting you know.
 
PONY, great post. I've been as confused as you about Wimbley. Lawson was clearly the more productive player in college, against both pass and run, and he's faster in the 40 and the short shuttle. I think if any DE/OLB pass rusher type gets piched top 12-15, it's going to be Lawson.
 
stinkypete said:
PONY, great post. I've been as confused as you about Wimbley. Lawson was clearly the more productive player in college, against both pass and run, and he's faster in the 40 and the short shuttle. I think if any DE/OLB pass rusher type gets piched top 12-15, it's going to be Lawson.

I'm relieved to hear I'm not the only one. Wimbley didn't even crack the starting lineup until his senior year and played no LB in college. His measurables are excellent, but not mind-blowing -- behind both Lawson and Mark Anderson, both of whom had far more impressive college careers. And he didn't dominate in post-season appearances. But he has all the buzz.
 
PonyExpress said:
The NFL.com profile on Wimbley is pretty much on the money as I see him. http://www.nfl.com/draft/profiles/2006/wimbley_kamerion

Thanks for the link! Want to see something funny? Try browsing through that site's evaluations of Wimbley, Lawson, Carpenter, Tapp, Kiwanuka, even Gocong and Wyche...every single one starts of with something like "X was a frustrating player to evaluate..." And in almost every case the reason cited was inconsistency. According to that evaluator, the only talented and consistent 3-4 LB prospect in America is A.J. Hawk (and maybe Greenway).
 
patchick said:
Thanks for the link! Want to see something funny? Try browsing through that site's evaluations of Wimbley, Lawson, Carpenter, Tapp, Kiwanuka, even Gocong and Wyche...every single one starts of with something like "X was a frustrating player to evaluate..." And in almost every case the reason cited was inconsistency. According to that evaluator, the only talented and consistent 3-4 LB prospect in America is A.J. Hawk (and maybe Greenway).

I believe the author of those pieces for GM jr is Russ Lande, a former scout for the Browns. He seems like a very irritable fellow. I can picture him throwing things at the screen watching these poor kids play...
 
Wimbley was a monster last season. Was the ACC sack leader(a conference which had Mario Williams, Manny Lawson, and Kiwanuka), before getting injured. He's a beast.
 
If Wimbley was such a monster why did he have only 26 total tackles in the entire 2005 season? Why did he only get 3.5 tackles for loss against the run the entire 2005 season? The fact he ended up with 7.5 sacks for the entire season can't compare with Mario Williams 14.5. Even Kiwi, who missed two games, had 9.5.
 
I didn't see Wimbley in the college season, but I was deeply impressed by his Senior Bowl film. He looked incredibly fast, and a notch faster off the snap than any other DEs that I observed.

It's hard to know where he stands on BB's board, but I think he does deserve some mid-first round attention.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

PatsFans.com LinkHub

𝕏 / Tweet
X.com - Patriots Had TE Jeremiah Franklin in for a tryout
Patriots News
twitter.com · by Ian
21h
📰
📰 Article
Mitchell Van Vooren - Track & Field - Marquette University Athletics
Player Info Link
gomarquette.com · by Clonamery
1d
📰
📰 Article
Dan Connolly Runs It Back - The Draw Play
Funny Link
thedrawplay.com · by ctpatsfan77
1d
📰
📰 Article
Patriots Sign TE Mitch Van Vooren and LB Riley Wilson; Release FB Brock Lampe
Patriots Player News
patriots.com · by mayoclinic
1d
𝕏 / Tweet
X.com - Patriots Transactions, Lampe Released, Patriots Sign 2
Patriots Player News
twitter.com · by jmt57
1d
📷
📷 Photo
Caleb Lomu During Minicamp 6/10/26
Patriots Photos
pflinks.patsfans.com · by Ian
1d
𝕏 / Tweet
X.com: Patriots signed linebacker Riley Wilson
twitter.com · by Ian
2d
𝕏 / Tweet
X.com - Patriots CB Marcellus Dial 100% Ahead of Training Camp
Patriots News
twitter.com · by Ian
2d
Patriots’ Vrabel Addresses Gabe Jacas Holdout: “We’re not going to put a timeline on it”
Vrabel Optimistic as Patriots Continue Contract Talks with Christian Gonzalez: “I Would Expect Him to Participate”
DeAndre Hopkins On Hand Ahead of Camp, Pondering Coaching Role
TRANSCRIPT: Mike Vrabel Pre-Training Camp Press Conference 7/24
MORSE: Pre-Camp Patriots Roster Projection and Training Camp Preview
Patriots News 07-19, A Big Summer For Williams, Boutte
MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis – 2026 Coaching Staff
MORSE: Patriots Positional Analysis – Secondary
Patriots News 07-12, Pre-Training Camp 53-Man Roster Projection
MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis – Linebackers and Special Teams
Back
Top