Search results

************, talk about being a snowflake. This change has been implemented in the college ranks since 2018 and nobody cares, it hasn't impacted the product a lick. Oh no, how can the very concept of masculinity itself deal with an average 0.5 return less per game (that's how much this rule has...

Lol, I just knew this was a Giardi article. Everyone was raving about Mac's offseason last year as well, at some point I'd really love it if the glowing reviews of him didn't focus specifically on off field stuff. Yeah, he's confident, he's a leader, he's working hard, that's all great. Can he...

To me Daniel Jones isn't worth the contract he got in any way, that's the formula for being stuck with a guy that can only be as good as his environment and won't elevate a team while paying 40 million for that privilege. I guess maybe that level of performance would warrant Mac's 5th year...

I won't give a numbers estimate because I have to see it to understand the context of what he looked like. Is he being asked to be the main driver of the offense and succeeding? Has he shown an ability to come from behind? Can he win games when the defense and running game are struggling? That's...

Pickett ranked 8th in the league in EPA/Play starting from Week 9. He was really bad to start then ended strongly and made a lot of plays to win games down the stretch, even if the box score numbers don't look pretty or the Steelers weren't relying on him to throw the ball a ton. There's a lot...

I don't think Mac Jones is hopeless, but if the hope resides in his rookie year where a ton of his production came in blowouts (ranked 24th out of 30 qualified QBs in EPA/Play in true game neutral situations, i.e., winning probability between 20-80%), I just think that's a limited player. He has...

Sure. It's just there's really nothing to talk about right now and this type of content is good discussion fodder. Obviously the odds of us looking back at this list in February, 2024 and finding it laughable are huge.

I have no issues with saying the list is bad, I disagree with a whole lot there. I just don't think it's unfeasible for rookies to be placed above certain starters.

So every rookie by definition should be slotted in at the very bottom of these rankings? Note that none of them were ranked highly at all either. What's the issue with believing Bryce Young should be a better QB in 2023 than Baker Mayfield, for instance?

And as of now these rankings are betting on said potential over what they've seen from Mac Jones thus far, which is perfectly valid. It's not like Mac Jones is either an unknown or has had great NFL success despite his lack of tools. He's been "meh", and analysts would rather have the guys who...

As of late first round QBs have tended to improve significantly from year 1 to year 2.

Do you believe any of those franchises would trade those guys straight up for Mac?

Trent Brown should be a lot better with a return to a familiar blocking scheme and Strange developing. Expect them to add a tackle tonight as well.

This team severely lacks blue chippers and they went out and got a blue chip prospect at a position to need, to boot. They didn't have a prototypical perimeter corner on the roster and now they do. Sky high value + positional need = excellent pick. Gonzalez was my "pie in the sky" scenario for...

Jones would have developed better playing for Urban Meyer as a rookie? Because those are the situations we're comparing here.

Oh, odds are that at least one of them will, 100%. It's just that they have a very viable avenue towards improving at the position and getting a good player there.

Pretty sobering to look at this and realize that the two teams that for sure have starters worse than Mac will both presumably be picking a QB high tonight.

Want? Deonte Banks. Believe they'll take either him, Lukas Van Ness, Zay Flowers or one of the top tier tackles if they slip.

Oh look, the same joke poster derrailing yet another thread with his gimmick. Have no clue why that continues to be allowed to happen here.

I'm aware of the whole "the martyrization of Mac Jones" agenda, I fully buy that you believe he was put in this impossible situation in 2022 and no QB in NFL history ever had to deal with such a horrific scenario. I just don't think it's true. You think Mac Jones would have been better off on...