PaulThePat
Rotational Player and Threatening Starter's Job
- Joined
- Nov 6, 2007
- Messages
- 1,447
- Reaction score
- 1,918
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.Being at the game, and seeing the replay, thought it was either a catch and a knee down, or he didn't catch it at all. Don't think there is much to whine about there.
17th row, 40 yard line lower level, behind the Jax bench.ya because being in the 3rd deck is a better view than the tv at home.
Being at the game, and seeing the replay, thought it was either a catch and a knee down, or he didn't catch it at all. Don't think there is much to whine about there.
When is a fumble an incomplete pass?
I thought he had his knee down at first, but CBS showed a still frame clearly displaying the ball coming out with neither knee on the ground.
It was a fumble.
Then he didn't have possession, never a catch. Too bang bang.
I know that you are a Colt fan and that will cloud your judgement on this, but Utecht took two steps before he was tackled.
There was nothing bang-bang about it. It was a fumble.
It was an incomplete pass because it was ruled so, however, I think its a really bad call or rule. The guy caught it, both feet down with possession.
I hate the way its called now where you have to control it all the way through to the lockeroom, put it in plastic and mail it UPS home before its a reception, bad rule, worse interpretations, imho.
Now you could make an argument that his knee was down before the ball came out, but I don't think that was conclusive either.
Troy Palolamala sp? had an interception against the Colts two years ago in the playoffs that was taken away because he didn't make a football move. Dude caught it, turned ran a full step, went down and the ground knocked it out, it gets ridiculous.