Smith sucker punches his own teammates. I could understand some interest there, but to call him a much better option is to ignore the significant issues he brings to the table.
That was years ago and yes it was bad, but it's not like he has ever been some multiple season cancer there. Hell, he carried that passing game for years and made Delhomme look a lot better than he was. He's playing great this year with a rookie, and Smith on the Pats offense would be lightening in a bottle. He can get in the middle, he can stretch the field, and he's better than almost any WR after the catch. For a small guy, he'll go up and grab balls with the best of them as well. He's waaaaayyy better than Ocho at this stage of their careers and it's not even close.
Yes, he'd showed some legit skills, but he'd also struggled without Boldin there in Arizona. There was a real question as to whether or not he could cut it as a true outside guy.
The Pats already had their inside guys. They needed someone to stretch the field and that's what they were hoping that Price could do. Breaston would do well in NE in my opinion. You have to remember that players have historically played a lot better with Brady. You mentioned Gaffney earlier or someone else did and he looked ten times better in NE than he did in Houston.
Burress was coming back from prison and has always been a problem for his coaches. He was not a better option.
Yes, and after all of that I trusted the guy to come back this season and play his heart out. Prison can do a lot for a guy like that and really give him that wake up call. It certainly did for Vick and he changed his attitude a lot. Burress seems to as well, and I don't see how you could deny this now after he has played pretty damn well this season. The only question with him was whether or not if he could play at the same level he was before since he had aged and been away from the sport, but I think he is playing alright this season. He's much better than Chad Johnson any day of the week, that's for sure and a much better RZ target. The Pats already have guys like Welker and Woodhead who use their quickness and speed to get around defenders. Burress could have been that physical presence similar to the TE's on this team.
Your first valid example, although his problems with dropping the ball would have been an issue.
I think he would have been just fine.
Floyd has never had a 50 catch season, has a problem playing full seasons, and is 30 years old himself. I didn't hate him, but I can't see crying about him. Rice was gone right away, although I liked the idea of the team getting him, and Jackson was franchised.
He has had his injury issues, but you can't expect that going into the next season. He wouldn't have costed a lot of money, and the guy has some damn good hands.
I can see your point on some of these players, and I was in favor of the team going after Rice, but there's not really anyone on the list who
The Pats simply weren't going to pay for Rice or for Jackson so I didn't even bother mentioning them. That just wasn't going to happen.
b.) is producing significantly more in a similar role and/or would clearly have gotten more playing time in the Patriots lineup.
What??? Chad Johnson has 200 yards and 11 catches for heaven's sake. Every player on this list could have easily been more effective than Chad this season here. Some things you stated may be debatable but this last point is simply not one of them.