- Joined
- May 1, 2008
- Messages
- 16,682
- Reaction score
- 3,686
Unfortunately, speed on defense is not something BB seems to value all that highly. Size and stoutness on the other hand is.
I'd like a fast attacking defense but that would require almost a complete rebuild. And for it to be truly effective, it would require a few years of high draft picks I suspect to get those dominant athletic JJ Watt/Fletcher Cox types.
I suspect BB's two gap more passive style is as much about the draft value of a perpetually winning team as it is about defensive preferences.
I think that you can build a faster and more aggressive defense without entirely abandoning some of BB's principles. But regardless, as a hypotethical, if you had been trying to evolve the Pats' D in that direction over the past 3 years, given where we had drafted and who was realistically available (sorry, no JJ Watt or Fletcher Cox, much as we might have wanted both), who would you have considered?
On the front 7, I think we should assume that Vince Wilfork and Jerod Mayo were a given as the backbone of any rebuilding of the defense. Those guys weren't going anwhere, and personally, I wouldn't want them to. I'm very happy with Chandler Jones.
I wanted a big DE with speed who could play in 3-4 or 4-3 schemes, particularly Carlos Dunlap in 2010, and I wanted the Pats to look at LBs with speed and playmaking ability who could play in both 4-3 and 3-4 schemes (Sean Lee and Daryl Washington were both on my list). Lavonte David was my binky last year, and I wanted projected day 3 (though they actually went 3rd round) guys like Demario Davis and Akiem Hicks who fit into a faster, more aggressive style but who were still strong at the point of attack. I have guys like Ziggy Ansah, Alec Ogletree and Dion Jordan on my short list this year, with guys like Kyle Van Noy, Anthony Barr and Trent Murphy high on my wish list for 2014 (obviously, I'd love a freak like Clowney, but I'm trying to keep this semi-realistic).
In the secondary, I wanted a playmaking safety in 2010, and hoped Earl Thomas might slip to 22. I'm happy with Devin McCourty evolving in that role now. I badly wanted Richard Sherman in 2011. I liked big CB/S hybrids like Brandon Hardin and Trumaine Johnson last year.
I'd be curious what kind of players you would envision fitting into a "different kind of defense", and how different a defense you have in mind.