- Joined
- Feb 4, 2018
- Messages
- 15,877
- Reaction score
- 20,286
Sure, he may not be in the All time great conversation, but McNabb was a 6 time Pro Bowl QB. He was very good. Reid had a reputation in the NFL as a horrible game manager and a guy who couldn't get over the hump losing 3 straight NFCCG's choking twice at home. The Eagles main weakness was at WR and they dominated the 2004 season when they got Owens.Is McNabb a HOF QB? He was a good QB, but nobody compares him with Brady, Mahomes, Montana, or any of the other elite QBs.
Reid had a hell of a record in PHI (6 Div, 9 playoff appearances, a SB) in 14 years.
This what I'm saying, you guys love to excuse all of Belichick's losing seasons and then make excuses for the winning seasons of other HCs.
In 25 years, Reid had a total of 3 losing seasons. That's pretty amazing. That's with multiple QBs, and only 1 will make it to the HOF (6 seasons). It is what it is.
I have my issues with Bill in regards to roster building/drafting, benching a guy in the Super Bowl, etc., but there's no way you'd take Reid over Belichick if both teams were equal.