arrellbee
Rotational Player and Threatening Starter's Job
- Joined
- May 11, 2005
- Messages
- 1,084
- Reaction score
- 0
All of the points made, which certainly are excellent ones for what is important for the ILB, just simply miss the point.
Certainly, it seems as though folks feel as though Beisel has been lacking in these and I would agree. And the things you mention CAN be improved on with experience and coaching.
However, none of these excellent points are what is critically wrong with Beisel.
One of the things that is critically wrong is that he doesn't TRY to disengage from a block, or at least try all that hard. If you don't disengage, you are playing exactly what the X's and O's offensive guy needs to have happen - a block that stays a block and doesn't let the LB loose to pursue and tackle. Simple. Even when he tries, it takes him forever to get away from the blocker. Note the play I mentioned in the 2nd post where Vrabel had been able to disengage his guy and take almost 5 strides before Beisel got loose and Colvin was able to come across from the totally opposite side of the LOS and still get there a half step behind Beisel.
The other critical flaw is that this guy just does not try to get to the runner in traffic, even when the runner is in front of him !! I'll do the Jets game as soon as I get a couple hours. There are at least a couple plays (actually I think at least 3) that show this dramatically. Even if you read my comments on the Jags game, you will see that, even in this game, in two plays where the runner was coming right by the position he was in, he never laid a hand on the runner or even managed to push toward the runner.
Do you think that these flaws can be coached ? I have serious doubts. I would certainly agree that most if not all of the other comments were about issues that can get significantly better with coaching and experience, but these don't seem to fit into that category.
As Mike the Brit said: "What BB didn't say: he's tough, committed and has excellent technique."
And McBee: "No aggressiveness, no instincts, gone. He can lift all the weights in the world, but it won't matter."
One thing seems like a complete consensus. Belichick IS the master talent judge and we'll know by final cuts or the first few games of the season what his evaluation of Beisel is !! Soooooo hard to wait, but at least camp is here !!
/Cheers
Certainly, it seems as though folks feel as though Beisel has been lacking in these and I would agree. And the things you mention CAN be improved on with experience and coaching.
However, none of these excellent points are what is critically wrong with Beisel.
One of the things that is critically wrong is that he doesn't TRY to disengage from a block, or at least try all that hard. If you don't disengage, you are playing exactly what the X's and O's offensive guy needs to have happen - a block that stays a block and doesn't let the LB loose to pursue and tackle. Simple. Even when he tries, it takes him forever to get away from the blocker. Note the play I mentioned in the 2nd post where Vrabel had been able to disengage his guy and take almost 5 strides before Beisel got loose and Colvin was able to come across from the totally opposite side of the LOS and still get there a half step behind Beisel.
The other critical flaw is that this guy just does not try to get to the runner in traffic, even when the runner is in front of him !! I'll do the Jets game as soon as I get a couple hours. There are at least a couple plays (actually I think at least 3) that show this dramatically. Even if you read my comments on the Jags game, you will see that, even in this game, in two plays where the runner was coming right by the position he was in, he never laid a hand on the runner or even managed to push toward the runner.
Do you think that these flaws can be coached ? I have serious doubts. I would certainly agree that most if not all of the other comments were about issues that can get significantly better with coaching and experience, but these don't seem to fit into that category.
As Mike the Brit said: "What BB didn't say: he's tough, committed and has excellent technique."
And McBee: "No aggressiveness, no instincts, gone. He can lift all the weights in the world, but it won't matter."
One thing seems like a complete consensus. Belichick IS the master talent judge and we'll know by final cuts or the first few games of the season what his evaluation of Beisel is !! Soooooo hard to wait, but at least camp is here !!
/Cheers