- Joined
- Dec 22, 2008
- Messages
- 15,686
- Reaction score
- 17,150
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.Bold prediction: this contract is going to make the 49ers the laughingstock of the NFL within 4 years (absolute maximum).
Agreed. I think a good amount of others will too. IMO, this is the worst longterm contract in NFL history, just passing Flacco.
Kaepernick has been blessed with a near 07 level offense his first two years (Crabtree/Davis/Gore, then Boldin added and now Johnson) and an elite OL. Despite that, he's a bottom 10 QB in terms of passing ability, and threw for 3,197 yards with that lineup.
Bold prediction: this contract is going to make the 49ers the laughingstock of the NFL within 4 years (absolute maximum).
"Near 07 level" might be the most hilarious hyperbole I've ever read.
A completely healthy Crabtree would have been the 3rd, maybe 4th best receiver in 07, Vernon Davis is a better blocker than a receiver, Gore is merely fine, and Boldin's best days are far behind him. His OL is very good, you are correct on that.
Kaepernick makes a lot of things happen. Wilson is probably better, but I'd much rather have Kaepernick than Flacco.
Crabtree is a top 10-15 WR. Davis would be near Gronk/Graham's level with Brady, Boldin is still a top 20 WR, and Gore has been a yearly probowler.
This is the same guy who had to call a timeout on the first play of the 2nd half of a playoff game because he forgot to put on his arm band that had the plays on it. He also threw a horrible pick vs Sea and went long against Sherman when there was no real urgency to gamble at the time.
He has a cannon and may be the best running QB out there so they had to sign him but..... that kind of money for a guy who doesnt seem all that bright is scary.
"Near 07 level" might be the most hilarious hyperbole I've ever read.
A completely healthy Crabtree would have been the 3rd, maybe 4th best receiver in 07, Vernon Davis is a better blocker than a receiver, Gore is merely fine, and Boldin's best days are far behind him. His OL is very good, you are correct on that.
Kaepernick makes a lot of things happen. Wilson is probably better, but I'd much rather have Kaepernick than Flacco.
I'm not saying Crabtree isn't good, but you're overrating every other player there. Gore is very reliable and consistent but he rushed for over 100 yards all of 3 times this season. Davis is up and down. And, notably, Boldin and Crabtree barely played together.
To compare that supporting cast to the second best WR of all-time in his prime, one of the best slot receivers ever, a top OL, and a host of solid supporting cast members like Faulk, Gaffney, and Stallworth... well, I think that's hyperbole.
interesting only a 12 million dollar signing bonus.
I think both of the arguments for and against the 49ers having an Patriots 07 type of offense are going overboard to make your points. I think it is silly to say their offense is nearly as talented, but come on.
I don't think that that offense is nearly as talented, but Vernon Davis a better blocker than a receiver?!? I would put him on the second tier of TEs. He is not in the elite world like Gronk or Jimmy Graham, but he was 6th in receiving yards for a TE and second in receiving TDs.
Frank Gore is going on his third straight year of over 1100 yards (it is his first year of the three where he didn't get over 1200). He was 9th in rushing yards, second in rushing plays over 20 yards, and 6th in rushing TDs. That makes him a top back in the league.