I agree with that but half that list is a freaking joke. If we talking about a popularity contest, maybe.
Cam Newton being on there while Joe Flaco and Alex Smith not making the list is a joke. Brees above Tom is very crappy too. Even Tebow deserves it more. I guess everyone's obsession with yards and his record makes it ok, but to anyone with a little bit of knowledge you could see his loss in the playoffs coming a mile away because of his inefficiency.
I guess if we grade players on effort rather than overall contribution towards actually winning, sure. But if we take into consideration winning, Cam Newton's td-to-interception efficiency was damn near bottom of the league. Can't have a winning record with someone playing like that.
For rookies, he belongs, but no way in hell for football players. Put Steve Smith on the list instead. He's the main reason why Newton looked the way he did and gets no credit for it. Nothing made me cringe my teeth more than hearing how Newton was making Smith look good.