SITE MENU
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.JJ McCarthy the accuracy can be taught.The more I watch of Maye, the more I don't want him. Holds the ball too long, has a tendency to underthrow his receivers, and his athleticism is overrated to the extend that I don't think it translates into the NFL.
Yep. It’s a whole different ballgame. Just listen to the podcast with Brian Hoyer and Tom Curren.A lot of QB’s look great in College and on film but bust in the Pro’s because their talent does not translate to the Pro’s.
Absolutely at this moment in time he does lack touch, but layering passes can be taught. I feel like if he sits for a year or most of the 1st year and learns and practices well with the staff that he can reach a higher ceiling than JD. I feel the same about Maye, that he needs to sit and learn for awhile.
You know. I have not looked into Penix yet. I was turned off by injury history. Will give him a peekYep. It’s a whole different ballgame. Just listen to the podcast with Brian Hoyer and Tom Curren.
Most important qualities are leadership and the ability to do progression reads in the face of a dicey pocket.
That’s why a gamble on Penix is enticing. He has both.
We trade back a few spots. Get the elite LT. And then can be in the running for Penix with a slight tradeup.
I mean Lance started one year, he opted out of 2020 so didn't play football and was drafted in 2021. I feel like that was an apples-oranges kind of thing. You're right that there are many athletic guys that don't develop touch and JJ might not, but your comparison was trash. Do better.How did that work out for SF & Trey Lance
There are plenty of athletic first QB’s who never develop touch or other intangibles needed to be successful
I mean Lance started one year, he opted out of 2020 so didn't play football and was drafted in 2021. I feel like that was an apples-oranges kind of thing. You're right that there are many athletic guys that don't develop touch and JJ might not, but your comparison was trash. Do better.
I wasn't trying to change your mind because no one gives a **** about our opinions.Actually it was a good comparison of a guy who wasn’t projected to go into the first round & then his athletics shot him up the
Board before the draft
Your defense of McCarthy was lame, & did nothing to change my view
Only time will tell …..
That is definitely common ground we can both agree onI wasn't trying to change your mind because no one gives a **** about our opinions.
If there are real issues with the top QB candidates, I would hope our QB whisperers see this, and more.Bedard is comparing maye to bortles and saying he might need to sit for year or 2 .
Yikes!!
Bedard is not a qb whisperer and does not know his ass from his elbow. I trust Tim Hasselbacks opinion.If there are real issues with the top QB candidates, I would hope our QB whisperers see this, and more.
FOMO?I have a feeling that Minnesota is going to throw a haul at someone to move up to get a QB. They have put alot into their Defense so far kinda like they plan on drating alot of offense. So I am curious if anyone would down to 11 and what it would take?
I would be hesitant to move out of FOMO on a QB.
GIYF!FOMO?
We rolled the dice on a "franchise" QB at 15.He can not afford to pass over a potential franchise QB. Its time to roll the dice a little.
We didn't roll the dice when we picked the only QB left at 15,We rolled the dice on a "franchise" QB at 15.
Not arguing, but scared we blow it on the most difficult position to evaluate...again.
It's cherry picking, but I found an article that said the bust rate for QBs picked with the first 3 picks was 70%.
You don't have to look hard to find QBs that didn't pan out with the #1 overall.
Bedard thought Rob Gronkowski was a bust, just for reference. I'm not saying he's wrong in this particular case, just adding context.Bedard is comparing maye to bortles and saying he might need to sit for year or 2 .
Yikes!!