This is the most pivotal game in both Brady and Manning's career.

[Ring 6]

Montana never lost a super, never threw a super bowl Int. that means something. The guy was clutch in unreal ways. Losing the super bowl hurts because you did not win it. Look at Dan Marino. If that guy had a ring or 2. His legacy would be totally different. You can not really compare stats between Montana and brady. 2 different eras. If Montana played today, I think its pretty safe to say he would put up great numbers

So last year Joe Flacco was better than Russell Wilson because he didn't lose a SB?

As for the bolded part, what are you talking about? 31 teams do not win it, being 2nd is not worse than being 11th.

Your argument is now that if Brady lost early in the playoffs in 2007 and 2011 that would make him a better QB than leading his team to the SB before losing.

As far as Marino, what does him not having a ring have to do with 4 CCG wins and 4 SB wins being better than 6 CCG wins and 4 SB wins.

You are just wrong here. And it isn't even close.

 

[Ring 6]

Marv levy, Great coach, we all know that 4 straight superbowls is a remarkable accomplishment, but they did not win any of those games, no one talks about Marv Levy being one of the greatest coaches of all time. No one talks about Bud Grant. No one talks about Dan Reeves

What are you talking about?
You are comparing people who never won SBs to Tom Brady? Really?
Levy is better than the guy who never made it to any SBs, and he is better than the guy who is 0-2.

Who was more successful? John Elway who led his team to the SB 5 times and won 2 rings, or Jim Plunkett who only got there twice and has the same number of rings?

 

[Joey007]

Let me put this in a nutshell.

Peytons 43-8 debacle is forever smashed into his legacy.

Brady beats the same team 28-24 the very next year.

Case closed.