Maybe you need to read that again, Brady didn't even play his rookie year.
Yeah simple question, better DEAL, the DEAL. What does it matter if the Jets are closer to being good than Skins? That isn't the question. That has absolutely nothing to do with the deal itself, neither does age, McNabb is still in his prime and so is Holmes and they are both 1 year deals. Look if the Bills had done the same deal I would say the Bill got a better deal than the Jets, it has nothing to do with my feelings for the Jets.
The Redskins are getting a Pro Bowl player for a FULL season the Jets are getting an excellent receiver for 3/4's of the season. You tell me what is easier to find Pro Bowl QB or up and coming receiver? Now what position has a FAR, FAR greater impact? Thank you, McNabb is the better deal.