The ball security issues have me worried, but the new running style seems to be working and there are a lot of new Maroney fans.
But watching him this season, and hearing all the talk of running style, made me think of a post I read over at
Advanced NFL Stats which compared running performance. Basically, there are high-variance and low-variance runners in the NFL. The high-variance guys are more likely to give you a big play, but also more likely to lose yardage. The low-variance guys are the plodders who are consistently churning out yards for you. Sometimes they'll even have the same YPC, but the main difference is in the number of big plays and the number of bad plays for losses.
The argument they made was that if you were a good team, you wanted the consistency so you could rely on it, so you'd want a low-variance runner. If you weren't a good team, you wanted the high-variance runner because it would be the only chance you could win, so you'd be willing to trade some negative plays for the explosive plays.
Well Maroney's dancing style always fit that high-variance style of running. He would frustrate fans with his happy feet, getting caught in the backfield for losses which would often kill drives. His explosive plays weren't really appreciated because we had an offense that could generate big plays, especially in 2007. So he was seen as inconsistent, and the fans hated watching drives end because he got caught in the backfield.
Now he seems to be dancing less, hitting the hole, taking what's there. His YPC is down this season because he's traded some explosiveness by taking a few yards in the hole. There haven't been as many negative plays, and he's relying on the line to open up the holes now. But he's gained that consistency that we wanted, and now the fans are with him.
The 2007 offense was like a dream, but too good to be true. Many will agree that in terms of offensive balance, we were at our best when we had a guy like Dillon who could churn out yards on a consistent basis. BB and Maroney have worked to make it happen too, and kudos to Maroney for these weekly meetings. I can't think of a case where I saw a runner change his style so much over a season.
So Maroney has actually been less effective in terms of YPC, but Pats fans are happier because he's been more consistent. I hope he continues to improve and hold onto the ball, as he's still quite young and obviously has a ton of talent.