Boy I hope that Scar's coaching was just for giggles. I'm not stoked on Costanzo in the first round. I'd much rather see us draft Carimi.
Yes, I have strong reservations for Castonzo that high; the issue which makes this murky is the picture which emerges when examining the NE round one & two draft history starting with Klemm and Light, and running through Mankins and Vollmer.
-- All four prior Top OL draftees were
extremely athletic coming out of college; three were TE to OT conversions in college; all played more than one position during their tenure.
-- All were 1st team All-Conference as seniors.
-- Light, Mankins, and Vollmer came from programs which either started with a relationship with BB or Scar, or quickly developed one (I can't be sure if Light's coaches had a prior link, but NE grabbed two of Light's linemates off the street so Scar liked the base material Purdue developed).
Castonzo and Solder both bring those same elements to the draft:
-- Both are extremely athletic as measured by the Combine drills and workouts.
-- Both are 1st team All-Conference (and both All American too).
-- Solder's senior year OL coach developed Tom Ashworth; I don't think I need to go into depth on the BC O-line tradition and how BB and Scar relate.
-- And to put icing on the cake, both were team captains.
It's easy for us to pick holes in these kid's games, but if BB and Scar believe NE would be better for a new stud OT (left or right depending on flipping Vollmer), both fit the Scarnecchia/Belichick profile, providing the base material Scar has demonstrated he can develop into a consistent starter.
I'd still rather have a shiny new DE, but Bob Kraft has the draft room buried so deep my mind-meld with BB loses sync, and he likes to take off on his own tangents whenever that happens.