I don't think that this is a black and white question.
Every season... the first goal has got to be winning the AFC East.... to me, if we make that goal, then we have had some success.
Secondly, we've got to try to get homefield throughout... an incredibly tough second goal... but one worth shooting for... if we can achieve this goal (regardless of overall record)... then we have had more success than in just achieving goal one.
Third: Win Game One of the playoffs.... to me, the playoffs are a "one game at a time" thing...each win is a complete success... and should be enjoyed as one... we are continuing to watch our team play while others sim. to us are already talking draft of "next year".
Fourth: Win Game Two of the playoffs (if we got our second goal then it's the AFC Championship... if not, then we go to the Championship... doesn't really matter.... the goal is to win each game one at a time).
Fifth: Win Game Three of the playoffs (might be the SB... might be the AFC Championship... again, doesn't matter... one game at a time).
Sixth: If nec., Win Game Four of the playoffs (depending upon goal 2... this may or may not be nec.)
To me, EVERY year that we win the AFC East is HUGE... some of you guys were there when we had no shot at the AFC East almost every year (If only the K Gun were real... and we could shoot Marino with it!!!!)... too many fans, in my humble opinion, have gotten a little too big for their britches... winning the AFC East is HUGE... and I celebrate it every year. The rest is gravy.
Is the overall goal winning the Superbowl... yes... but what counts as a succ. season? To me, it's winning the AFC East.... and then it's one step at a time, one game at a time, towards the SB.
To those that have the SB or bust mentality... you are entitled to your opinion... but I was (and am) thrilled with last year.... and will continue to be thrilled with last year.
The Pats have been playing for almost 50 years.... almost forty of those years have been within the AFC East....we've only won 9 division championships in those years... NINE... we only made the AFL Championship ONCE pre merger and got spanked by the Bolts (almost as bad as '85... but the Bears made sure we couldn't move in Q3..... shoot the Fridge with that K-Gun, too.)....to me, that says something... that is something. To win a SB in the NFL is hard, fellas.... expectations can be tough... I expect to make the playoffs this year.... I think that we will win the AFC East... that's about all that I can say... for me, just saying that is a HUGE statement.... SB or bust, to me that's just crazy. I'd rather be happy with a Division championship and then be thirsty for more than be completed saddened by one loss later in the year, fellas!
Just my opinion, though... but boy, you guys are a tough bunch!