PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans

Peter King reviews Holley's "War Room" book


Status
Not open for further replies.

Patspsycho

Veteran Starter w/Big Long Term Deal
Joined
Aug 13, 2009
Messages
9,921
Reaction score
0
Highly fascinating:


Book review:
War Room: The Legacy of Bill Belichick and the Art of Building the Perfect Team, (itbooks), by Michael Holley.

Anything Holley writes, after his memorable Patriot Reign insider's tome about New England's rise to power, I'll read. This didn't let me down. It's a book about Belichick, chief lieutenant Scott Pioli and wunderkind Thomas Dimitroff growing the Patriots, then Pioli and Dimitroff splitting off to run the show in Kansas City and Atlanta, respectively. The explanatory parts of how a draft is put together (Holley is especially strong analyzing the Chiefs' way of picking players under Pioli) merges well with stories about trades and draft strategy.

I especially liked Holley fleshing out how the three men disagree. Their football backbone is the same, Holley writes. But whereas Belichick, who gives the vibe of a conservative team manager, takes chances on off-field risks like tight end Aaron Hernandez, an outside-the-box thinker like Dimitroff won't touch problem children.

Dimitroff had black dots -- meaning he wouldn't draft them -- on both Florida's Brandon Spikes and Florida's Hernandez in the 2010 draft. Owner Arthur Blank even pressed Dimitroff on why he had so many black-dot guys, many more than other teams in the league. "[Dimitroff] was an extension of a Belichick Tree, not a Belichick monolith,'' Holley writes. "He typed a few notes in his iPad about general-managing in his third year. Be true to yourself, he wrote. Remember your roots: tough, honest, organic.''

Holley captures a dinner at the Senior Bowl in Mobile with Pioli and Dimitroff, in which they discuss the philosophy of building a team, right down to how they want their draft rooms to feel on draft day.

Said Pioli: "I need silence. I need limited activity.''
"We have things you would never allow in your draft room,'' Dimitroff said.
"Like what?'' Pioli said.
Like Falcons board of directors members Hank Aaron and Andrew Young sitting in the draft room if they choose. Presumably, it makes Blank happy.
"That's how I see it differently,'' Pioli said to Dimitroff. "Draft day is not entertainment in that room, okay? Last year, I spent $30 millon guaranteed on one pick. I've gotta have a clear head to make that decision. Do Fortune 500 companies have people coming into their boardrooms? I don't know, maybe I'm taking myself too seriously.''
"Respectfully, Scott, if my mistakes are because we have seven limited partners and a couple business associates in there, then my personal opinion is I'm not the right person for the job.''
There's more talk, and Pioli said: "We've got to be careful about how much of football loses its soul. Because we got to where we are because we kept the football soul.

Fascinating, too, is the discussion of last spring's Julio Jones trade. Blank urged Dimitroff to feel out his friends in the business to see if the trades makes as much sense to them as it does to the Falcons. Dimitroff called Belichick. "As a friend,'' Belichick told him, "I wouldn't do it.'' His advice was to not move up 21 picks in the first round, with all the attendant costs, to get Jones. Stick where you are, and take a good receiver like Pitt's Jonathan Baldwin. He's just as good, Belichick says.

Of course, the Falcons dealt for Jones. And Pioli took Baldwin for the Chiefs at the bottom of the round.

Holley also shows much of Belichick's human side -- at his father and mentor Steve's funeral. At the funeral of a man the Browns fired when he was coach, the father of Thomas Dimitroff, longtime scout Tom Dimitroff. ("Would you mind if I put a rose on your husband's casket?''
Belichick said to Tom Dimitroff's widow. She allowed it.) When protégé Josh McDaniels got fired in Denver last year, Belichick told him: "Call your parents. Go see them. Make sure they know you're okay because I know that they're going to go through this and feel terribly about it.''

Other tidbits Patriot fans will enjoy:

• Scouts were ticked off in 2006 that Belichick overrode their reports and picked Laurence Maroney in the first round (apparently on the strong advice of Josh McDaniels' brother Ben, one of the Maroney's college coaches) and Chad Jackson in the second round -- even after receivers coach Brian Daboll said he didn't want to coach Jackson.

• After the Boston Herald reported (incorrectly, as it turned out) that the Patriots had taped a Rams practice before the 2002 Super Bowl, Belichick went to his captains and asked if he should address the team about it -- just before the Super Bowl they played against the Giants in February 2008. The captains said no, so Belichick didn't talk to the team about it.

• Defensive keystone Vince Wilfork didn't like the trade of Mike Vrabel to Kansas City before the 2009 season. "That trade ticks me off. Right now. Still. When I heard about it, I said, 'What the f--- is going on?' If you want to talk about the Patriot Way, you start with Vrabel.' ''

• It wasn't just management that came to dislike free agent signee Adalius Thomas. It was the players. Tedy Bruschi on Thomas: "He started to question a lot of things in meeting. 'Why are we doing that?' 'Why don't we just do this?' He stopped buying in on what the coaches thought. He really did think he had all the answers, you know? And that's what he turned into: the answer man. That's when I was on my way out and I was glad to get out at that point.''

Regardless of your rooting interests, War Room is going to take you into the inner game of pro football. I recommend it highly.


Read more: After beating Patriots, Steelers look to be the best of the AFC - Peter King - SI.com
 
Last edited:
Good posting. I read this earlier and also found it great. I liked the other tidbits towards the end the most.

Regards,
Chris
 
I read the book several years ago. I remember reading about Ernie Adams and how people weren't sure what exactly he did. Once the Spygate scandal broke, I remember thinking that Adams was connected to the analysis.
 
interesting that BB surrounds himself with smart football guys, but does not trust them enough to let them make sound football decisions
 
interesting that BB surrounds himself with smart football guys, but does not trust them enough to let them make sound football decisions

You make a good point. It'll be interesting to see once the season is over if Mr. Kraft mandates a return to the previous structure. I think BB has too many balls in the air right now. Just my 2 cents worth.
 
You make a good point. It'll be interesting to see once the season is over if Mr. Kraft mandates a return to the previous structure. I think BB has too many balls in the air right now. Just my 2 cents worth.

Don't remember anyone saying that when we were 5-1, or when we were 14-2 last year. Funny how one close loss on the road to an elite team changes everything for some of you.

The last few Pioli-Belichick joint drafts blew chunks. The Maroney and Chad Jackson stories happened when Pioli was here, so I'm not sure what effect people think a dedicated player personnel guy will have.
 
Don't remember anyone saying that when we were 5-1, or when we were 14-2 last year. Funny how one close loss on the road to an elite team changes everything for some of you
So when things go well, people don't complain that much. When things go terribly, they complain more.

Alert the press. A new breakthrough on human behavior has been discovered.
 
Last edited:
You make a good point. It'll be interesting to see once the season is over if Mr. Kraft mandates a return to the previous structure. I think BB has too many balls in the air right now. Just my 2 cents worth.

regarding the draft or coaching? (or both?)

(I wouldn't agree re the draft. I would agree re. coaching.)
 
I'm just glad to read it's not some Belichick Butt Kissing book given how I feel about the team right now.

Those days are over. Everyone is looking forward to the day he either retires or is fired. At least, that's all I've heard today.
 
I thought about pre-ordering it, but I'm stuck in a number theory proof class for the next month, so that's probably a bad idea. I'll probably ask for it for Christmas and try to get it read after Christmas before school starts again. Any glimpse into BB's war room fascinates me. The simple idea that Belichick suggested drafting Baldwin is football porn for my brain :lol2:
 
Last edited:
In my opinion, Michael Holley is a brilliant, insightful writer. It's obvious he's a good listener and a keen observer. Since he's joined Glen Ordway on the Big Show, he's morphed into a different guy than the one he was on the 10-2 show with Dale Arnold. My opinion only, but it's sad what's happened to him.
 
Not addressing Tomase's BS piece was a mistake.

A huge mistake.

As a fan, I recall how that story completely ruined the energy I had going into that weekend. Completely.

Don't you think the players could've had a similar response? Especially the guys who had been on the dynasty squads?

Big mistake by the captains - Belichick should've used Tomase's smear piece to create the us against everyone mentality that carried us to 18-0 that season. Instead, I saw players with little energy, little passion, little urgency and no disdain for their opponent.
 
Just pre ordered it...

Last year I emailed Holley with an idea for a book, about following some kids prior to the draft and paralleling their stories the Patriots Draft.. then following the draftees through their first game..

Who would have thunk, it was already in process... he did not respond to my idea, this book was already in the works..

This is the book I have been waiting for..
 
Not addressing Tomase's BS piece was a mistake.

A huge mistake.

As a fan, I recall how that story completely ruined the energy I had going into that weekend. Completely.

Don't you think the players could've had a similar response? Especially the guys who had been on the dynasty squads?
I'm not sure what the pro players thought about it but I'm 100% sure that it wasn't remotely similar to what you, as a diehard fan, thought. I'm guessing they were thinking "I"M IN THE ******* SUPERBOWL IN TWO DAYS!" and "WHAT TWISTS AND STUNTS ARE THEY GOING TO USE TO GET TUCK FREED UP" and not "what's that turdball Tomase writing today"
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure what the pro players thought about it but I'm 100% sure that it wasn't remotely similar to what you, as a diehard fan, thought. I'm guessing they were thinking "I"M IN THE ******* SUPERBOWL IN TWO DAYS!" and "WHAT TWISTS AND STUNTS ARE THEY GOING TO USE TO GET TUCK FREED UP" and not "what's that turdball Tomase writing today"

That's certainly possible.

But to me, the accusations were so deflating b/c, if true, they were of more substance than the spygate ones. Spygate, to me, those accusations meant nothing. Maybe the taping would've been more substantial a charge, if it hadn't been such BS.

Not only that, even Jonathan Kraft has admitted it was a distraction as the organization, coaching staff included, had to spend time dealing with it - and how to address it. You might as well try and spin something positive out of that distraction.

I maintain the appropriate response would've been to address the accusations to the players, claim they are false, and use it again as a rallying cry. In a way, it was sitting there waiting to be used as motivation - waiting for Belichick to tell his players they had even more to prove.

Instead, it went unaddressed, and each individual player was left to think what they want. And maybe some thought the past rings had less validity, maybe some were just exhausted of all the BS, maybe some didn't care at all - but either way, it was a missed opportunity.
 
Last edited:
Mannn!!!!!!

I can't buy it until November 8th.....November freakin' 8th!!!!

I thought for sure it was available on Kindle today....I could be dead by November 8th!!!

I didn't read Holley's first boook. I opted to read The Blueprint by Christopher Price, which covers the same ground, it was good.

Management Secrets of The New England Patriots is an excellent read which looks at all the behind the scenes workings of the 2001, 2002, and 2003 seasons. They also have volume 2 which covers 2004 but I didn't get that one.

The biography on Belichick--'The Education of a Coach' is an excellent read.

I've been waiting for this to release, should be interesting.
 
interesting that BB surrounds himself with smart football guys, but does not trust them enough to let them make sound football decisions

Wrong. What this means is what I suspected for years, which is that those terrible drafts from 2005-2008 were because Josh McDaniels was destroying the draft room, as efficiently as we saw him destroy the Denver Broncos roster in two seasons. King's article says Belichick wasn't listening to his draft people but McDaniels' kid brother, or McDaniels himself who worked out many of the busts we took. I also remember an article (anyone else remember this one) about McDaniels and how he moved up in the Patriots organization, starting early on by putting together spreadsheets analyzing cornerbacks. Apparently Belichick was impressed and gave him increasing responsibility in part because of that analysis on defensive backs. I wouldn't be surprised if our horrible drafting of D-backs is also related to McDaniels.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


MORSE: Patriots Day 2 Draft Opinions
Patriots Wallace “Extremely Confident” He Can Be Team’s Left Tackle
It’s Already Maye Day For The Patriots
TRANSCRIPT: Patriots OL Caedan Wallace Press Conference
TRANSCRIPT: Eliot Wolf’s Day Two Draft Press Conference
Patriots Take Offensive Lineman Wallace with #68 Overall Pick
TRANSCRIPT: Patriots Receiver Ja’Lynn Polk’s Conference Call
Patriots Grab Their First WR of the 2024 Draft, Snag Washington’s Polk
2024 Patriots Draft Picks – FULL LIST
MORSE: Patriots QB Drake Maye Analysis and What to Expect in Round 2 and 3
Back
Top