He hasn't officially picked the Giants yet, but everything Merril Hoge is saying points to him picking the Giants. He is spouting his theory that every team that has played the Pats this year have played the Pats tougher the second time around. Funny, weren't the Pats accused for the first time for running up the score the second meeting against the Bills when they beat them 56-10 after beating them 38-7 first time.
He also didn't take into account the Pats totally crushed the Dolphins in both games and in the second game they abandoned the gameplan in the second half up 28-0 to try to get Brady and Moss the TD titles in front of the home crowd. I don't know how Hoge could ever argue that the Dolphins the Dolphins played tougher when that game was over by the end of the first half and the Pats were playing school yard football on offense in the second half.
As for the Chargers, the Chargers were a different team the second half of the season than they were in the first half. I bet they would have played every team they played in September tougher if they met them in January even with injuries.
As for the Jets, the first game was in perfect conditions and the second game was during a N'orEaster. I think the weather had as much to do with the Jets playing the Pats tougher as anything Mangini strategized.
I think Hoge is already trying to come up with any bogus reason to pick against the Pats. I fully expect him to pick the Giants when the ESPN picks are online later this week.