- Joined
- Sep 22, 2008
- Messages
- 4,329
- Reaction score
- 2,486
My post, which started the discussion:
Where is there anything there about ONE playoff run?
This is my point about people moving the goalposts. I never said that Luck was the best QB in the league. I never said he was the third best, either, for that matter. I'd rank the QBs something like this:
Brady (38)
Rodgers (32)
Roethlisberger (33)
Brees (35)
Rivers (34)
Luck (26)
P. Manning (39) *
The asterisk on Manning is because I don't know exactly where to slot him, since I don't know how much of last year was because he just wore, and how much was on his injury.
So I've got Luck at #6 or #7 and rising, and at least 6 years younger than the rest of the group, while all the QBs above him would be either holding steady or falling.
That's why you take him as the Brady replacement.
Fair enough. It seems I missed that aspect when skimming through this thread.
People may make a Wilson argument, but I'd side with you on luck in that regard.
I'd probably drop Brees and have E. Manning in that list as (down a few) well (as much as that pains me)
Edit: drop Brees down a few and have eli in the mix. Posting from my phone...always an expirament...