SITE MENU
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.Tony Dungy is more than entitled to his opinion that Peyton Manning is more dangerous than Tom Brady. He’s also smart to point out that, when Bill Belichick went for it on fourth-and-2 from his own 28 this season rather than punting to Manning, it was affirmation of how good Manning is. But I’m not sure how that decision reflects on a comparison between Manning and Tom Brady. Dungy made that leap, saying he would punt the ball to Tom Brady with a minute left facing the same situation. Before anyone says, “Well, if Dungy feels that way, it’s settled,” consider Dungy’s got an understandable affinity for Manning and that Dungy’s career playoff record as a head coach was 9-10 and he was one-and-done in 6 of the 11 seasons his teams in Tampa and Indianapolis made the playoffs (and 5-10 if you take out 2006, which wouldn’t be fair to do because that was his best season). I would take Bill Belichick’s decision-making prowess over Dungy’s 10 times out of 10.
And when was the last time and how often have Tony and the Goathead won "the big one" again?Brady and Bill deserve every shot they get because they haven't won the big one in a while. Win again and win often then cats will respect you again.
Am I the only one having a hard time following Tony's logic?
1. BB wouldn't punt it to Paycheck.
2. I, St. Tony, would have punted (with Quiet Strength) to Brady.
3. Therefore, Peycheck is a better QB than Brady. QED.
A high school kid would get a D for this kind of muddled thinking.
Dungy's just bitter that Belichick will always be considered a better coach than him. He should be worried about paying attention to what's left of his family instead.
I'm sorry but LOL. I was not expecting that.Dungy's just bitter that Belichick will always be considered a better coach than him. He should be worried about paying attention to what's left of his family instead.
I have to agree with you.Classless post. Quite disgusted actually.
So much for quiet strength.
Classless post. Quite disgusted actually.