- Joined
- Sep 7, 2006
- Messages
- 68,333
- Reaction score
- 105,293
Yes. And without his safety and int we win it.
Prove this.
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.Yes. And without his safety and int we win it.
The author of the article is Scott Kacsmar. It was pointed on in another recent thread that Kacsmar is a fan of the Colts and the Steelers. If you look through Kacsmar's columns you get the feeling you're on Bleacher Report, not CHFF.
http://www.patsfans.com/new-england...chff-dont-ever-click-again-please-sticky.html
Apparently Kerry Byrne is spending the bulk of his time working for SI and Yahoo now, leaving Kacsmar to handle CHFF. There once was a time when it seemed like CHFF analyzed stats and then reached a conclusion, but it appears now that they are pretty much like all the others that stir the pot in order to generate clickks; they do just the opposite: they form an opinion (conclusion) first, and then search for information (data, stats) to support that theory. It's bad science and it's bad journalism.
Super Bowl 46: Tom Brady clutch 4th down completion - YouTube
I just watched it again (see link) and I agree, it was a great throw…but I think with the game more or less decided the Giants were trying to just stay in front of the receivers…Branch had a nice cushion there.
Perhaps that is my point…so many playoff games but the throw that comes to mind is a 16yard curl pattern with the game more or less over.
Don't get me wrong - he is still the only QB I want on my team…but to say he is a clutch postseason QB/GOAT, whatever is just not true (to me). He is the best pre-snap QB ever and makes great reads…maybe I just am forgetting some great throws that you guys may remember.
I honestly don't know how you all can put Tom Brady in the GOAT discussion....
All you ever bring up is the rings 'argument'. Do any of you actually know that he only threw for 1TD in the 3 games they played during the first superbowl win?
Well, that was just the first one that popped into my mind. The 70 yard throw by Brady to Moss at the end of SB 42 was as unbelievable a throw as I've ever seen. 70 yards, on a rope, into a window about the size of a mailbox....and the throw is maybe 2-3 inches shorter than perfect....a Giant defender *BARELY* gets a finger on it, or Moss catches it and the Pats probably win that game.
Randy Moss SB 42 almost catch - YouTube
Super Bowl 46: Tom Brady clutch 4th down completion - YouTube
I just watched it again (see link) and I agree, it was a great throw…but I think with the game more or less decided the Giants were trying to just stay in front of the receivers…Branch had a nice cushion there.
Perhaps that is my point…so many playoff games but the throw that comes to mind is a 16yard curl pattern with the game more or less over.
Don't get me wrong - he is still the only QB I want on my team…but to say he is a clutch postseason QB/GOAT, whatever is just not true (to me). He is the best pre-snap QB ever and makes great reads…maybe I just am forgetting some great throws that you guys may remember.
I wouldn't call that a good game. At least not by his standards.