2007 Interactive NFL Mock Draft Discussion

[SamBamsFan]

Interesting that 2/3 of those teams are a base 3-4.

Ah, that was my handicap, trying to get players that fit for the Falcons. LOL. Anyway, I love my draft for the holes I needed to fill. I thought that I got 4 potential starters, a immediate nickle back, and two skill players w/ greta upside. I'd like to listen to grades as well. thanks all.

 

[SamBamsFan]

The Jaguars would love to know what people think as well.
R1 J. Anderson
R2 E. Weddle
R3 Q. Black
R4 J. Beck

DE, S, LB, QB

I like all your picks a lot. I thought that you might of drafted Weddle a little early, but if he was the player that you targeted in the second round I fully understand.
B+

 

[Irish Hooligan]

I like all your picks a lot. I thought that you might of drafted Weddle a little early, but if he was the player that you targeted in the second round I fully understand.
B+

Just missed on a falling Brandon Meriwether, S was the biggest need.
Thanks for the input.

 

[VJCPatriot]

Dolphins Draft Summary:

Round 1 (9) - Levi Brown, OT

Rationale: The Dolphins need OL help badly. Levi Brown will anchor their line at LT for years to come. Some scouts even like him better than Joe Thomas.

Other considerations at this pick were Amobi Okoye who was snatched up 1 pick earlier and Jamaal Anderson. Ted Ginn Jr. was considered too high of a reach at this point in a draft deep with wide receivers.

Round 2 (40) - Sidney Rice, WR

Rationale: The Dolphins recently lost McMichael and Welker. Chambers has proven to be very inconsistent and overrated. The Dolphins offense was a weakness and they could use more playmakers. Rice has a 6'4 frame, runs a 4.5 40, and is very explosive. He might very well have the best hands in the draft and is just what the doctor ordered to help the stagnant Fins offense.

Jason Hill was a consideration here but I decided to go with the guy I believe has the most upside. If Joe Staley or Grubbs had slid to this spot instead I believe I would have pulled the trigger as the Dolphins poor OL is a huge area of need. I am happy to get a very talented player with great upside in a different need position.

Round 2 (60) - Drew Stanton, QB

Rationale: Board consensus. I was not displeased with this pick but would have preferred Kevin Kolb who I hear that the Dolphins are really in love with. I was not allowed to change this pick although Kolb was still on the board when I checked in. Stanton has a gifted pro quality arm so it is not too much of a downgrade. I happen to like Kolb's mobility and pocket presence a little more but all in all this pick still addresses the Fins need at QB.

Round 3 (71) - Tim Crowder, DE

Rationale: The Fins are thin at defensive end after Jason Taylor. I hear that they are moving to a 3-4 defense so they will need depth at that position. Crowder I believe is ready to contribute immediately and is solid against both the run and the pass. He collected 10.5 sacks last year and should make it even harder for teams to double team Jason Taylor.

Other considerations at this pick were Josh Gattis, Zak DeOssie, and Stewart Bradley. I went with the big man as the draft is deep in safeties and I was thinking a decent linebacker would last until round 4. I felt Crowder was more talented than those guys and improved the Fins DL so that's the guy I took.

Round 4 (108) - Yamon Figurs, WR

Rationale: Yamon Figurs is a quick return specialist that opened eyes at the combine with a blazing 4.3 40. The Dolphins needed a guy to replace the void left by Wes Welker much as they would hate to admit it. They do so cheaply in the second day with a 4th round pick. Look for Figurs to make an immediate impact on special teams and as an occasional deep threat or reverse play option. Figurs is a dangerous return man who averaged 28 yards on kick returns and has returned a punt as well as a kickoff for TDs in his college career.

Other considerations for this selection included Wendling and Chris Davis. Wendling however was snatched up shortly before this pick and I liked Figurs return game better than Chris Davis. Figurs deep speed also adds another dimension to the Dolphins offense that may prove a nice complement to keep double teams off Rice.

In all the Dolphins considerably overhauled their offensive unit by adding an anchor at LT for the next 10 years and two new wideouts that should become playmakers for them offensively and contribute to their special teams unit.

Defensively they added depth to their defensive line, and if Crowder comes on as expected, that will allow them to bring even more pressure on the QB from their DL. Jason Taylor will always be gameplanned for, but adding pressure from the opposite side as well will test the mettle of any offensive line.

The Dolphins defense was a strength last year so I believe that their weakest unit had to be addressed first. With this type of draft the Dolphins could emerge to challenge the Jets for second place in the AFC East.

 

[chunkypony]

(EDIT: deleted quoted spam draft, hope that's ok! it was highly specialized spam, but spam nonetheless...especially in this thread)

well, at least this moron read the thread topic before he posted this crap. What a spamming idiot.

 

[SamBamsFan]

As the (mock) GM I'm drafting Okoye here still.

 

[VJCPatriot]

Am I Smarter than the Dolphins GM? - Raw draft slot value compared

My draft:
1. Levi Brown (Mock Slot 9) - (Actual Draft Slot 5). Slot value = +4
2A. Sidney Rice (Mock Slot 40) - (Actual Draft Slot 44). Slot value = -4
2B. Drew Stanton (Mock Slot 60) - (Actual Draft Slot 43). Slot value = +17
or Kevin Kolb (Mock Slot 60) - (Actual Draft Slot 36). Slot value = +24
3. Tim Crowder (Mock Slot 71) - (Actual Draft Slot 56). Slot value = +15
4. Yamon Figurs (Mock Slot 108) - (Actual Draft slot 74). Slot value = +34

My raw total draft slot value = +90 (With Stanton), +97 (With Kolb).
In terms of raw value I attained better players with later picks as opposed to where they went in the draft.

Dolphins Draft:
1. Ted Ginn (Slot 9) - (Mock Draft Slot 19). Slot value = -10
2A. John Beck (Slot 40) - (Mock Draft Slot 113). Slot value = -73
2B. Satele, Samson (Slot 60) - (Mock Draft Slot 89). Slot value = -29
3. Lorenzo Booker (Slot 71) - (Mock Draft Slot 95). Slot value = -24
4. Paul Soliai (Slot 108) - (Mock Draft Slot 85). Slot value = +23

Fins raw total draft slot value = -113

Obviously the real draft is going to be harder than a mock draft but in terms of projected value compared to our mock draft, the Dolphins were consistently reaching for players. Their draft went downhill from the top, once they passed on Brady Quinn. Big mistake. If Brady Quinn had been available in our mock draft it would have been a nobrainer for me to take him. Apparently the Fins GM checked his brain at the door. By round 2 they were desperate because Kolb was snatched right before them and they settled for Beck who I believe they had rated 4th after Russell, Quinn, and Kolb. The only pick where they gained relative value was with Soliai in the 4th round.

If I took the time to weight the slots by round, giving higher priority/scale to 1st round pick than 2nd round pick than 3rd round pick, etc. I believe that the Dolphins draft would have scored even WORSE in terms of draft slot value. Thanks for taking a look. I'm feeling pretty good that my draft, in terms of draft slot value, went a lot better than the Dolphins. I should have been hired as the Fins real GM for the 2007 draft!

2007 Interactive Mock Draft:
http://www.patsfans.com/new-england....php?t=53764&highlight=interactive+mock+draft

2007 Miami Draft Picks:
http://www.nfl.com/draft/drafttracker/team/MIA

 

[zarakotas5]

I'm surprised that this hasn't been revisited to compare what happened vs. what we picked.

I'm gonna brag a little. 2 bulls-eyes. The rest were pretty close. My biggest miss was picking Houston in the first at 27. He went at 41. Picked before NO got David.

 

[bakes781]

you asked for it...

ROUND 1

Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - JAMARCUS RUSSELL QB LSU 0
Lions- PushnPencils - CALVIN JOHNSON WR GEORGIA TECH 0
Browns- ironwasp - BRADY QUINN QB NOTRE DAME -19
Buccaneers- bakes781 - JOE THOMAS OT WISCONSIN 1
Cardinals- primetime - GAINES ADAMS DE CLEMSON 1
Redskins- Maroney TD - LARON LANDRY S LSU 0
Vikings- broadwayjoe - ADRIAN PETERSON RB OKLAHOMA 0
Falcons- SamBamsFan - AMOBI OKOYE DT LOUISVILLE -2
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - LEVI BROWN OT PENN STATE 4
Texans- A.C. Vegas - LEON HALL CB MICHIGAN -8
49ers- dryheat44 - PATRICK WILLIS LB MISSISSIPPI 0
Bills- stinkypete - LAWRENCE TIMMONS LB FLORIDA STATE -3
Rams- broadwayjoe - DARRELLE REVIS CB PITTSBURGH -1
Panthers- ice - GREG OLSEN TE MIAMI -17
Steelers- jct - ALAN BRANCH DT MICHIGAN -18
Packers- skaIownsIyou - REGGIE NELSON S FLORIDA -5
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - JAMAAL ANDERSON DE ARKANSAS 9
Bengals- patsfan55 - ADAM CARRIKER DE NEBRASKA 5
Titans- Patskers - TED GINN JR WR OHIO STATE 10
Giants- Seneschal2 - PAUL POSLUSZNY LB PENN STATE -14
Broncos- ayjackson - JUSTIN HARRELL DT TENNESSEE 5
Cowboys- Seymour93 - JOE STALEY OT CENTRAL MICHIGAN -6
Chiefs- tampabaypats12 - DWAYNE JARRETT WR USC -22
Patriots- mavfan2390 - MARSHAWN LYNCH RB CALIFORNIA 12
Jets- Flying Fungi - DWAYNE BOWE WR LSU 2
Eagles- Maroney39for6 - ROBERT MEACHEM WR TENNESSEE -1
Saints- zarakotas5 - CHRIS HOUSTON CB ARKANSAS -14
Patriots- mavfan2390 - MARCUS MCCAULEY CB FRESNO STATE -44
Ravens- Handel - JUSTIN BLALOCK OG TEXAS -10
Chargers- sebman2112 - MICHAEL GRIFFIN S TEXAS 11
Bears- chunkypony - BEN PATRICK TE DELAWARE -184
Colts- gomezcat - JON BEASON LB MIAMI 7

ROUND 2

Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - RYAN KALIL C USC -26
Lions- PushnPencils - JARVIS MOSS DE FLORIDA 17
Buccaneers- bakes781 - TANK TYLER DT NC STATE -47
Browns- ironwasp - AARON ROSS CB TEXAS 16
Bears- chunkypony - BEN GRUBBS OG AUBURN 8
Cardinals- primetime - TONY UGOH OT ARKANSAS -4
Falcons- SamBamsFan - ANTHONY SPENCER DE PURDUE 13
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - SIDNEY RICE WR SOUTH CAROLINA -4
Vikings- broadwayjoe - STEVE SMITH WR USC -10
49ers- dryheat44 - ANTHONY GONZALEZ WR OHIO STATE 10
Bills- stinkypete - DAYMEION HUGHES CB CALIFORNIA -52
Falcons- SamBamsFan - ARRON SEARS OT TENNESSEE 9
Panthers- ice - BRANDON MERIWEATHER S MIAMI 21
Steelers- jct - BRANDON SILER LB FLORIDA -194
Packers- skaIownsIyou - MICHAEL BUSH RB LOUISVILLE -53
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - ERIC WEDDLE S UTAH 11
Bengals- patsfan55 - LAMAR WOODLEY LB MICHIGAN 3
Titans- Patskers - JOSH WILSON CB MARYLAND -5
Giants- Seneschal2 - CRAIG DAVIS WR LSU 21
Rams- broadwayjoe - DAVID HARRIS LB MICHIGAN 5
Cowboys- Seymour93 - JASON HILL WR WASHINGTON STATE -23
Chiefs- tampabaypats12 - RYAN HARRIS OT NOTRE DAME -16
Seahawks- bakes781 - ZACH MILLER TE ARIZONA STATE 17
Broncos- ayjackson - VICTOR ABIAMIRI DE NOTRE DAME -1
Eagles- Maroney39for6 - TANARD JACKSON CB SYRACUSE -49
Saints- zarakotas5 - IKAIKA ALAMA-FRANCIS DE HAWAII 0
Jets- Flying Fungi - JONATHAN WADE CB TENNESSEE -25
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - DREW STANTON QB MICHIGAN STATE 17
Ravens- Handel - CHARLES JOHNSON DE GEORGIA -22
Chargers- sebman2112 - AUNDRAE ALLISON WR EAST CAROLINA -84
Jets- Flying Fungi - RAY MCDONALD DE FLORIDA -34
Buccaneers- bakes781 - AARON ROUSE S VIRGINIA TECH -25

ROUND 3


Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - QUENTIN MOSES DE GEORGIA 0
Lions- PushnPencils - TRENT EDWARDS QB STANFORD -26
Browns- ironwasp - BRIAN LEONARD RB RUTGERS 15
Buccaneers- bakes781 - RUFUS ALEXANDER LB OKLAHOMA -108
Cardinals- primetime - JUSTIN DURANT LB HAMPTON 21
Broncos- ayjackson - JAMES MARTEN OT BOSTON COLLEGE 3
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - TIM CROWDER DE TEXAS 15
Vikings- broadwayjoe - JOSH BEEKMAN OG BOSTON COLLEGE -58
Texans- A.C. Vegas - DOUG FREE OT NORTHERN ILLINOIS 49
Bills- stinkypete - ANTONIO PITTMAN RB OHIO STATE -33
Falcons- SamBamsFan - JOSH GATTIS S WAKE FOREST -75
49ers- dryheat44 - ANTONIO JOHNSON DE MISSISSIPPI ST -76
Steelers- jct - DAN BAZUIN DE CENTRAL MICHIGAN 15
Packers- skaIownsIyou - COURTNEY TAYLOR WR AUBURN -119
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - QUINCY BLACK LB NEW MEXICO 11
Titans- Patskers - BRANDON JACKSON RB NEBRASKA 17
Giants- Seneschal2 - SABBY PISCITELLI S OREGON ST 17
Rams- broadwayjoe - BRANDON MEBANE DT CALIFORNIA -3
Panthers- ice - BUSTER DAVIS ILB FLORIDA ST 14
Chiefs- tampabaypats12 - QUINN PIT**** DT OHIO ST -14
Seahawks- bakes781 - PAUL SOLIAI DT UTAH -23
Broncos- ayjackson - DAVID CLOWNEY WR VIRGINIA TECH -71
Cowboys- Seymour93 - USAMA YOUNG CB KENT ST -21
Saints- zarakotas5 - ANDY ALLEMAN OG AKRON 0
Jets- Flying Fungi - SAMSON SATELE OL HAWAII -29
Eagles- Maroney39for6 - TIM SHAW OLB PENN ST -74
Patriots- mavfan2390 - STEWART BRADLEY OLB NEBRASKA 4
Bills- stinkypete - TONY HUNT RB PENN ST 2
Chargers- sebman2112 - BRIAN ROBISON LB TEXAS -9
Bears- chunkypony - ANTHONY WATERS LB CLEMSON -2
Colts- gomezcat - LORENZO BOOKER RB FLORIDA ST 24
Chargers- sebman2112 - BRANDON FRYE OT VIRGINIA TECH -67
49ers- dryheat44 - ZAK DEOSSIE LB BROWN -19
Colts- gomezcat - XZAVIE JACKSON DE MISSOURI -200
Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - KENNY IRONS RB AUBURN 50

ROUND 4


Raiders- SeanBruschi54- DAVID IRONS CB AUBURN -94
Lions- PushnPencils - MARSHALL YANDA OT IOWA 15
Buccaneers- bakes781 - ERIC WRIGHT CB UNLV 49
Browns- ironwasp - MANNY RAMIREZ OG TEXAS TECH -14
49ers- dryheat44 - JOHN WENDLING S WYOMING -80
Cardinals- primetime - H.B. BLADES LB PITTSBURGH -74
Vikings- broadwayjoe - TARELL BROWN CB TEXAS -41
Texans- A.C. Vegas - J.L. HIGGINS WR UTEP 8
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - YAMON FIGURS WR KANSAS ST 34
Falcons- SamBamsFan - KENNY SCOTT CB GEORGIA TECH -100
49ers- dryheat44 - ALLEN BARBRE OT MISSOURI SOUTHERN -9
Bills- stinkypete - JACOBY JONES WR LANE 38
Packers- skaIownsIyou - A.J. DAVIS CB NC STATE 7
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - JOHN BECK QB BYU 73
Bengals- patsfan55 - TRAVAROUS BAIN CB HAMPTON -100
Titans- Patskers - FRED BENNETT CB SOUTH CAROLINA -8
Giants- Seneschal2 - MIKE OTTO OT PURDUE -50
Rams- broadwayjoe - JAY MOORE DE NEBRASKA 13
Panthers- ice - RHEMA MCKNIGHT WR NOTRE DAME -100
Steelers- jct - ADAM KOETS OT OREGON ST -70
Seahawks- bakes781 - KEVIN KOLB QB HOUSTON 84
Falcons- SamBamsFan - MIKE WALKER WR CENTRAL FLORIDA 42
Cowboys- Seymour93 - MARCUS THOMAS DT FLORIDA 1
Saints- zarakotas5 - ANTWAN BARNES LB FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL -11
49ers- dryheat44 - BRANDON HARRISON S STANFORD -20
Saints- zarakotas5 - CHRIS DAVIS WR FLORIDA ST -3
Saints- zarakotas5 - ERIC FRAMPTON S WASHINGTON ST -39
Patriots- mavfan2390 - MARVIN WHITE S TCU 13
Titans- Patskers - JON ABBATE LB WAKE FOREST -100
Chargers- sebman2112 - KOLBY SMITH RB LOUISVILLE -19
Bears- chunkypony - JORDAN PALMER QB UTEP -75
Colts- gomezcat - CHANSI STUCKEY WR CLEMSON -104
Steelers- jct - DALLAS BAKER WR FLORIDA -95
Falcons- SamBamsFan - DESHAWN WYNN RB FLORIDA -95
Ravens- Handel - PAUL WILLIAMS WR FRESNO ST 54
49ers- dryheat44 - DARIUS WALKER RB NOTRE DAME -100
Colts- gomezcat - COURTNEY BROWN CB CAL POLY -76
Ravens- Handel - TROY SMITH QB OHIO ST -37

 

[Seymour93]

Thanks bakes.

Looks like no horrible, bold reaches for me. I got great value in the 4th round with Marcus Thomas at +1.

As the real draft moves on in to the mid-to-later rounds, I bet teams are more inclined to reach for the players they like or need instead of going by BPA.

 

[VJCPatriot]

Nice recap Bakes. Now would you mind doing the math to see who were the biggest winners valuewise in the draft and who totaled the most reaches? I have to admit the GMs who got their guys spot on where the guy got drafted impressed me too. Although it's always nice to know that you got extra value out of the pick. I'm sure the guys that give -100 have to really hurt your raw score but if you weight the later rounds less, it should also hurt a bit less. I mean missing or reaching on a 1st round pick is going to hurt a lot more than missing or reaching on a 4th rounder imo. I'm unsure how they should be weighted though.

 

[bakes781]

I'm sure the guys that give -100 have to really hurt your raw score but if you weight the later rounds less, it should also hurt a bit less. I mean missing or reaching on a 1st round pick is going to hurt a lot more than missing or reaching on a 4th rounder imo. I'm unsure how they should be weighted though.

Yeah I had a hard time deciding what value to give those that went undrafted completely. Xzavie Jackson, Kenny Scott, Travarious Bain, Rhema McKnight & Darius Walker were the only ones that I believe didn't make the 7 round cut. I gave Jackson -200 because he was selected in the 3rd round, but after thinking about it a little more it should probably be -150.

I'll do a team by team comparison shortly.

 

[bakes781]

in a fuggles hop induced state last night, it came to me

we need a way to assess this draft

and here it is:

after the actual draft, we run the numbers of a drafted player's actual selection slot vs. where he was taken in our mock. the number of picks is irrelevant as an average will be taken.

example using the jets mock numbers and theoretical selection slots:

Bowe--25th
Wade--59th
McDonald--63rd
Satele--89th

assume:

Bowe--17th
Wade 57th
McDonald--68th
Satele--82nd

yields:

Bowe--(-8)
Wade--(-2)
McDonald--(+5)
Satele--(-7)

Totals--(-12)/#selections=(-3)

So the NYJ GM would get a (-3) value for this mock.

Any interest in this quantitative analysis of our mock? I suppose we can award a second category or ** for actually making an accurate selection.

under your scenario here is the results:

49ers- dryheat44 - ALLEN BARBRE OT MISSOURI SOUTHERN -9
49ers- dryheat44 - ANTHONY GONZALEZ WR OHIO STATE 10
49ers- dryheat44 - ANTONIO JOHNSON DE MISSISSIPPI ST -76
49ers- dryheat44 - BRANDON HARRISON S STANFORD -20
49ers- dryheat44 - DARIUS WALKER RB NOTRE DAME -100
49ers- dryheat44 - JOHN WENDLING S WYOMING -80
49ers- dryheat44 - PATRICK WILLIS LB MISSISSIPPI 0
49ers- dryheat44 - ZAK DEOSSIE LB BROWN -19
-36.75

Bears- chunkypony - ANTHONY WATERS LB CLEMSON -2
Bears- chunkypony - BEN GRUBBS OG AUBURN 8
Bears- chunkypony - BEN PATRICK TE DELAWARE -184
Bears- chunkypony - JORDAN PALMER QB UTEP -75
-63.25

Bengals- patsfan55 - ADAM CARRIKER DE NEBRASKA 5
Bengals- patsfan55 - LAMAR WOODLEY LB MICHIGAN 3
Bengals- patsfan55 - TRAVAROUS BAIN CB HAMPTON -100
-30.66

Bills- stinkypete - ANTONIO PITTMAN RB OHIO STATE -33
Bills- stinkypete - DAYMEION HUGHES CB CALIFORNIA -52
Bills- stinkypete - JACOBY JONES WR LANE 38
Bills- stinkypete - LAWRENCE TIMMONS LB FLORIDA STATE -3
Bills- stinkypete - TONY HUNT RB PENN ST 2
-9.6

Broncos- ayjackson - DAVID CLOWNEY WR VIRGINIA TECH -71
Broncos- ayjackson - JAMES MARTEN OT BOSTON COLLEGE 3
Broncos- ayjackson - JUSTIN HARRELL DT TENNESSEE 5
Broncos- ayjackson - VICTOR ABIAMIRI DE NOTRE DAME -1
-16

Browns- ironwasp - AARON ROSS CB TEXAS 16
Browns- ironwasp - BRADY QUINN QB NOTRE DAME -19
Browns- ironwasp - BRIAN LEONARD RB RUTGERS 15
Browns- ironwasp - MANNY RAMIREZ OG TEXAS TECH -14
-0.5

Buccaneers- bakes781 - AARON ROUSE S VIRGINIA TECH -25
Buccaneers- bakes781 - ERIC WRIGHT CB UNLV 49
Buccaneers- bakes781 - JOE THOMAS OT WISCONSIN 1
Buccaneers- bakes781 - RUFUS ALEXANDER LB OKLAHOMA -108
Buccaneers- bakes781 - TANK TYLER DT NC STATE -47
-26

Cardinals- primetime - GAINES ADAMS DE CLEMSON 1
Cardinals- primetime - H.B. BLADES LB PITTSBURGH -74
Cardinals- primetime - JUSTIN DURANT LB HAMPTON 21
Cardinals- primetime - TONY UGOH OT ARKANSAS -4
-14

Chargers- sebman2112 - AUNDRAE ALLISON WR EAST CAROLINA -84
Chargers- sebman2112 - BRANDON FRYE OT VIRGINIA TECH -67
Chargers- sebman2112 - BRIAN ROBISON LB TEXAS -9
Chargers- sebman2112 - KOLBY SMITH RB LOUISVILLE -19
Chargers- sebman2112 - MICHAEL GRIFFIN S TEXAS 11
-33.6

Chiefs- tampabaypats12 - DWAYNE JARRETT WR USC -22
Chiefs- tampabaypats12 - QUINN PIT**** DT OHIO ST -14
Chiefs- tampabaypats12 - RYAN HARRIS OT NOTRE DAME -16
-17.33

Colts- gomezcat - CHANSI STUCKEY WR CLEMSON -95
Colts- gomezcat - COURTNEY BROWN CB CAL POLY -76
Colts- gomezcat - JON BEASON LB MIAMI 7
Colts- gomezcat - LORENZO BOOKER RB FLORIDA ST 24
Colts- gomezcat - XZAVIE JACKSON DE MISSOURI -150
-58

Cowboys- Seymour93 - JASON HILL WR WASHINGTON STATE -23
Cowboys- Seymour93 - JOE STALEY OT CENTRAL MICHIGAN -6
Cowboys- Seymour93 - MARCUS THOMAS DT FLORIDA 1
Cowboys- Seymour93 - USAMA YOUNG CB KENT ST -21
-12.25

Dolphins- VJCPatriot - DREW STANTON QB MICHIGAN STATE 17
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - LEVI BROWN OT PENN STATE 4
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - SIDNEY RICE WR SOUTH CAROLINA -4
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - TIM CROWDER DE TEXAS 15
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - YAMON FIGURS WR KANSAS ST 34
13.2

Eagles- Maroney39for6 - ROBERT MEACHEM WR TENNESSEE -1
Eagles- Maroney39for6 - TANARD JACKSON CB SYRACUSE -49
Eagles- Maroney39for6 - TIM SHAW OLB PENN ST -74
-41.33

Falcons- SamBamsFan - AMOBI OKOYE DT LOUISVILLE -2
Falcons- SamBamsFan - ANTHONY SPENCER DE PURDUE 13
Falcons- SamBamsFan - ARRON SEARS OT TENNESSEE 9
Falcons- SamBamsFan - DESHAWN WYNN RB FLORIDA -95
Falcons- SamBamsFan - JOSH GATTIS S WAKE FOREST -75
Falcons- SamBamsFan - KENNY SCOTT CB GEORGIA TECH -100
Falcons- SamBamsFan - MIKE WALKER WR CENTRAL FLORIDA 42
-29.71

Giants- Seneschal2 - CRAIG DAVIS WR LSU 21
Giants- Seneschal2 - MIKE OTTO OT PURDUE -107
Giants- Seneschal2 - PAUL POSLUSZNY LB PENN STATE -14
Giants- Seneschal2 - SABBY PISCITELLI S OREGON ST 17
-20.75

Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - ERIC WEDDLE S UTAH 11
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - JAMAAL ANDERSON DE ARKANSAS 9
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - JOHN BECK QB BYU 73
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - QUINCY BLACK LB NEW MEXICO 11
26

Jets- Flying Fungi - DWAYNE BOWE WR LSU 2
Jets- Flying Fungi - JONATHAN WADE CB TENNESSEE -25
Jets- Flying Fungi - RAY MCDONALD DE FLORIDA -34
Jets- Flying Fungi - SAMSON SATELE OL HAWAII -29
-21.5

Lions- PushnPencils - CALVIN JOHNSON WR GEORGIA TECH 0
Lions- PushnPencils - JARVIS MOSS DE FLORIDA 17
Lions- PushnPencils - MARSHALL YANDA OT IOWA 15
Lions- PushnPencils - TRENT EDWARDS QB STANFORD -26
1.5

Packers- skaIownsIyou - A.J. DAVIS CB NC STATE 7
Packers- skaIownsIyou - COURTNEY TAYLOR WR AUBURN -119
Packers- skaIownsIyou - MICHAEL BUSH RB LOUISVILLE -53
Packers- skaIownsIyou - REGGIE NELSON S FLORIDA -5
-42.5

Panthers- ice - BRANDON MERIWEATHER S MIAMI 21
Panthers- ice - BUSTER DAVIS ILB FLORIDA ST 14
Panthers- ice - GREG OLSEN TE MIAMI -17
Panthers- ice - RHEMA MCKNIGHT WR NOTRE DAME -100
-20.5

Patriots- mavfan2390 - MARCUS MCCAULEY CB FRESNO STATE -44
Patriots- mavfan2390 - MARSHAWN LYNCH RB CALIFORNIA 12
Patriots- mavfan2390 - MARVIN WHITE S TCU 13
Patriots- mavfan2390 - STEWART BRADLEY OLB NEBRASKA 4
-3.75

Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - JAMARCUS RUSSELL QB LSU 0
Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - KENNY IRONS RB AUBURN 50
Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - QUENTIN MOSES DE GEORGIA 0
Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - RYAN KALIL C USC -26
Raiders- SeanBruschi54- DAVID IRONS CB AUBURN -94
-14

Rams- broadwayjoe - BRANDON MEBANE DT CALIFORNIA -3
Rams- broadwayjoe - DARRELLE REVIS CB PITTSBURGH -1
Rams- broadwayjoe - DAVID HARRIS LB MICHIGAN 5
Rams- broadwayjoe - JAY MOORE DE NEBRASKA 13
3.5

Ravens- Handel - CHARLES JOHNSON DE GEORGIA -22
Ravens- Handel - JUSTIN BLALOCK OG TEXAS -10
Ravens- Handel - PAUL WILLIAMS WR FRESNO ST 54
Ravens- Handel - TROY SMITH QB OHIO ST -37
-3.75

Redskins- Maroney TD - LARON LANDRY S LSU 0
0

Saints- zarakotas5 - ANDY ALLEMAN OG AKRON 0
Saints- zarakotas5 - ANTWAN BARNES LB FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL -11
Saints- zarakotas5 - CHRIS DAVIS WR FLORIDA ST -3
Saints- zarakotas5 - CHRIS HOUSTON CB ARKANSAS -14
Saints- zarakotas5 - ERIC FRAMPTON S WASHINGTON ST -39
Saints- zarakotas5 - IKAIKA ALAMA-FRANCIS DE HAWAII 0
-11.16

Seahawks- bakes781 - KEVIN KOLB QB HOUSTON 84
Seahawks- bakes781 - PAUL SOLIAI DT UTAH -23
Seahawks- bakes781 - ZACH MILLER TE ARIZONA STATE 17
26

Steelers- jct - ADAM KOETS OT OREGON ST -70
Steelers- jct - ALAN BRANCH DT MICHIGAN -18
Steelers- jct - BRANDON SILER LB FLORIDA -194
Steelers- jct - DALLAS BAKER WR FLORIDA -95
Steelers- jct - DAN BAZUIN DE CENTRAL MICHIGAN 15
-72.4

Texans- A.C. Vegas - DOUG FREE OT NORTHERN ILLINOIS -49
Texans- A.C. Vegas - J.L. HIGGINS WR UTEP 8
Texans- A.C. Vegas - LEON HALL CB MICHIGAN -8
-16.33

Titans- Patskers - BRANDON JACKSON RB NEBRASKA 17
Titans- Patskers - FRED BENNETT CB SOUTH CAROLINA -8
Titans- Patskers - JON ABBATE LB WAKE FOREST -100
Titans- Patskers - JOSH WILSON CB MARYLAND -5
Titans- Patskers - TED GINN JR WR OHIO STATE 10
-17.2

Vikings- broadwayjoe - ADRIAN PETERSON RB OKLAHOMA 0
Vikings- broadwayjoe - JOSH BEEKMAN OG BOSTON COLLEGE -58
Vikings- broadwayjoe - STEVE SMITH WR USC -10
Vikings- broadwayjoe - TARELL BROWN CB TEXAS -41
-27.25

 

[bakes781]

However I don't think that's the acurate way to calculate who did best so here is how it breaks down under mine:

49ers- dryheat44 - ALLEN BARBRE OT MISSOURI SOUTHERN 9
49ers- dryheat44 - ANTHONY GONZALEZ WR OHIO STATE 10
49ers- dryheat44 - ANTONIO JOHNSON DE MISSISSIPPI ST 76
49ers- dryheat44 - BRANDON HARRISON S STANFORD 20
49ers- dryheat44 - DARIUS WALKER RB NOTRE DAME 100
49ers- dryheat44 - JOHN WENDLING S WYOMING 80
49ers- dryheat44 - PATRICK WILLIS LB MISSISSIPPI 0
49ers- dryheat44 - ZAK DEOSSIE LB BROWN 19
39.25

Bears- chunkypony - ANTHONY WATERS LB CLEMSON 2
Bears- chunkypony - BEN GRUBBS OG AUBURN 8
Bears- chunkypony - BEN PATRICK TE DELAWARE 184
Bears- chunkypony - JORDAN PALMER QB UTEP 75
67.25

Bengals- patsfan55 - ADAM CARRIKER DE NEBRASKA 5
Bengals- patsfan55 - LAMAR WOODLEY LB MICHIGAN 3
Bengals- patsfan55 - TRAVAROUS BAIN CB HAMPTON 100
36

Bills- stinkypete - ANTONIO PITTMAN RB OHIO STATE 33
Bills- stinkypete - DAYMEION HUGHES CB CALIFORNIA 52
Bills- stinkypete - JACOBY JONES WR LANE 38
Bills- stinkypete - LAWRENCE TIMMONS LB FLORIDA STATE 3
Bills- stinkypete - TONY HUNT RB PENN ST 2
25.6

Broncos- ayjackson - DAVID CLOWNEY WR VIRGINIA TECH 71
Broncos- ayjackson - JAMES MARTEN OT BOSTON COLLEGE 3
Broncos- ayjackson - JUSTIN HARRELL DT TENNESSEE 5
Broncos- ayjackson - VICTOR ABIAMIRI DE NOTRE DAME 1
20

Browns- ironwasp - AARON ROSS CB TEXAS 16
Browns- ironwasp - BRADY QUINN QB NOTRE DAME 19
Browns- ironwasp - BRIAN LEONARD RB RUTGERS 15
Browns- ironwasp - MANNY RAMIREZ OG TEXAS TECH 14
16

Buccaneers- bakes781 - AARON ROUSE S VIRGINIA TECH 25
Buccaneers- bakes781 - ERIC WRIGHT CB UNLV 49
Buccaneers- bakes781 - JOE THOMAS OT WISCONSIN 1
Buccaneers- bakes781 - RUFUS ALEXANDER LB OKLAHOMA 108
Buccaneers- bakes781 - TANK TYLER DT NC STATE 47
46

Cardinals- primetime - GAINES ADAMS DE CLEMSON 1
Cardinals- primetime - H.B. BLADES LB PITTSBURGH 74
Cardinals- primetime - JUSTIN DURANT LB HAMPTON 21
Cardinals- primetime - TONY UGOH OT ARKANSAS 4
25

Chargers- sebman2112 - AUNDRAE ALLISON WR EAST CAROLINA 84
Chargers- sebman2112 - BRANDON FRYE OT VIRGINIA TECH 67
Chargers- sebman2112 - BRIAN ROBISON LB TEXAS 9
Chargers- sebman2112 - KOLBY SMITH RB LOUISVILLE 19
Chargers- sebman2112 - MICHAEL GRIFFIN S TEXAS 11
38

Chiefs- tampabaypats12 - DWAYNE JARRETT WR USC 22
Chiefs- tampabaypats12 - QUINN PIT**** DT OHIO ST 14
Chiefs- tampabaypats12 - RYAN HARRIS OT NOTRE DAME 16
17.33

Colts- gomezcat - CHANSI STUCKEY WR CLEMSON 95
Colts- gomezcat - COURTNEY BROWN CB CAL POLY 76
Colts- gomezcat - JON BEASON LB MIAMI 7
Colts- gomezcat - LORENZO BOOKER RB FLORIDA ST 24
Colts- gomezcat - XZAVIE JACKSON DE MISSOURI 150
70.4

Cowboys- Seymour93 - JASON HILL WR WASHINGTON STATE 23
Cowboys- Seymour93 - JOE STALEY OT CENTRAL MICHIGAN 6
Cowboys- Seymour93 - MARCUS THOMAS DT FLORIDA 1
Cowboys- Seymour93 - USAMA YOUNG CB KENT ST 21
12.75

Dolphins- VJCPatriot - DREW STANTON QB MICHIGAN STATE 17
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - LEVI BROWN OT PENN STATE 4
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - SIDNEY RICE WR SOUTH CAROLINA 4
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - TIM CROWDER DE TEXAS 15
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - YAMON FIGURS WR KANSAS ST 34
14.8

Eagles- Maroney39for6 - ROBERT MEACHEM WR TENNESSEE 1
Eagles- Maroney39for6 - TANARD JACKSON CB SYRACUSE 49
Eagles- Maroney39for6 - TIM SHAW OLB PENN ST 74
41.33

Falcons- SamBamsFan - AMOBI OKOYE DT LOUISVILLE 2
Falcons- SamBamsFan - ANTHONY SPENCER DE PURDUE 13
Falcons- SamBamsFan - ARRON SEARS OT TENNESSEE 9
Falcons- SamBamsFan - DESHAWN WYNN RB FLORIDA 95
Falcons- SamBamsFan - JOSH GATTIS S WAKE FOREST 75
Falcons- SamBamsFan - KENNY SCOTT CB GEORGIA TECH 100
Falcons- SamBamsFan - MIKE WALKER WR CENTRAL FLORIDA 42
48

Giants- Seneschal2 - CRAIG DAVIS WR LSU 21
Giants- Seneschal2 - MIKE OTTO OT PURDUE 107
Giants- Seneschal2 - PAUL POSLUSZNY LB PENN STATE 14
Giants- Seneschal2 - SABBY PISCITELLI S OREGON ST 17
39.75

Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - ERIC WEDDLE S UTAH 11
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - JAMAAL ANDERSON DE ARKANSAS 9
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - JOHN BECK QB BYU 73
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - QUINCY BLACK LB NEW MEXICO 11
26

Jets- Flying Fungi - DWAYNE BOWE WR LSU 2
Jets- Flying Fungi - JONATHAN WADE CB TENNESSEE 25
Jets- Flying Fungi - RAY MCDONALD DE FLORIDA 34
Jets- Flying Fungi - SAMSON SATELE OL HAWAII 29
22.5

Lions- PushnPencils - CALVIN JOHNSON WR GEORGIA TECH 0
Lions- PushnPencils - JARVIS MOSS DE FLORIDA 17
Lions- PushnPencils - MARSHALL YANDA OT IOWA 15
Lions- PushnPencils - TRENT EDWARDS QB STANFORD 26
14.5

Packers- skaIownsIyou - A.J. DAVIS CB NC STATE 7
Packers- skaIownsIyou - COURTNEY TAYLOR WR AUBURN 119
Packers- skaIownsIyou - MICHAEL BUSH RB LOUISVILLE 53
Packers- skaIownsIyou - REGGIE NELSON S FLORIDA 5
46

Panthers- ice - BRANDON MERIWEATHER S MIAMI 21
Panthers- ice - BUSTER DAVIS ILB FLORIDA ST 14
Panthers- ice - GREG OLSEN TE MIAMI 17
Panthers- ice - RHEMA MCKNIGHT WR NOTRE DAME 100
38

Patriots- mavfan2390 - MARCUS MCCAULEY CB FRESNO STATE 44
Patriots- mavfan2390 - MARSHAWN LYNCH RB CALIFORNIA 12
Patriots- mavfan2390 - MARVIN WHITE S TCU 13
Patriots- mavfan2390 - STEWART BRADLEY OLB NEBRASKA 4
18.25

Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - JAMARCUS RUSSELL QB LSU 0
Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - KENNY IRONS RB AUBURN 50
Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - QUENTIN MOSES DE GEORGIA 0
Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - RYAN KALIL C USC 26
Raiders- SeanBruschi54- DAVID IRONS CB AUBURN 94
34

Rams- broadwayjoe - BRANDON MEBANE DT CALIFORNIA 3
Rams- broadwayjoe - DARRELLE REVIS CB PITTSBURGH 1
Rams- broadwayjoe - DAVID HARRIS LB MICHIGAN 5
Rams- broadwayjoe - JAY MOORE DE NEBRASKA 13
5.5

Ravens- Handel - CHARLES JOHNSON DE GEORGIA 22
Ravens- Handel - JUSTIN BLALOCK OG TEXAS 10
Ravens- Handel - PAUL WILLIAMS WR FRESNO ST 54
Ravens- Handel - TROY SMITH QB OHIO ST 37
30.75

Redskins- Maroney TD - LARON LANDRY S LSU 0
0

Saints- zarakotas5 - ANDY ALLEMAN OG AKRON 0
Saints- zarakotas5 - ANTWAN BARNES LB FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL 11
Saints- zarakotas5 - CHRIS DAVIS WR FLORIDA ST 3
Saints- zarakotas5 - CHRIS HOUSTON CB ARKANSAS 14
Saints- zarakotas5 - ERIC FRAMPTON S WASHINGTON ST 39
Saints- zarakotas5 - IKAIKA ALAMA-FRANCIS DE HAWAII 0
11.17

Seahawks- bakes781 - KEVIN KOLB QB HOUSTON 84
Seahawks- bakes781 - PAUL SOLIAI DT UTAH 23
Seahawks- bakes781 - ZACH MILLER TE ARIZONA STATE 17
41.33

Steelers- jct - ADAM KOETS OT OREGON ST 70
Steelers- jct - ALAN BRANCH DT MICHIGAN 18
Steelers- jct - BRANDON SILER LB FLORIDA 194
Steelers- jct - DALLAS BAKER WR FLORIDA 95
Steelers- jct - DAN BAZUIN DE CENTRAL MICHIGAN 15
78.4

Texans- A.C. Vegas - DOUG FREE OT NORTHERN ILLINOIS 49
Texans- A.C. Vegas - J.L. HIGGINS WR UTEP 8
Texans- A.C. Vegas - LEON HALL CB MICHIGAN 8
21.67

Titans- Patskers - BRANDON JACKSON RB NEBRASKA 17
Titans- Patskers - FRED BENNETT CB SOUTH CAROLINA 8
Titans- Patskers - JON ABBATE LB WAKE FOREST 100
Titans- Patskers - JOSH WILSON CB MARYLAND 5
Titans- Patskers - TED GINN JR WR OHIO STATE 10
28

Vikings- broadwayjoe - ADRIAN PETERSON RB OKLAHOMA 0
Vikings- broadwayjoe - JOSH BEEKMAN OG BOSTON COLLEGE 58
Vikings- broadwayjoe - STEVE SMITH WR USC 10
Vikings- broadwayjoe - TARELL BROWN CB TEXAS 41
27.25

 

[broadwayjoe]

However I don't think that's the acurate way to calculate who did best so here is how it breaks down under mine:

49ers- dryheat44 - ALLEN BARBRE OT MISSOURI SOUTHERN 9
49ers- dryheat44 - ANTHONY GONZALEZ WR OHIO STATE 10
49ers- dryheat44 - ANTONIO JOHNSON DE MISSISSIPPI ST 76
49ers- dryheat44 - BRANDON HARRISON S STANFORD 20
49ers- dryheat44 - DARIUS WALKER RB NOTRE DAME 100
49ers- dryheat44 - JOHN WENDLING S WYOMING 80
49ers- dryheat44 - PATRICK WILLIS LB MISSISSIPPI 0
49ers- dryheat44 - ZAK DEOSSIE LB BROWN 19
39.25

Bears- chunkypony - ANTHONY WATERS LB CLEMSON 2
Bears- chunkypony - BEN GRUBBS OG AUBURN 8
Bears- chunkypony - BEN PATRICK TE DELAWARE 184
Bears- chunkypony - JORDAN PALMER QB UTEP 75
67.25

Bengals- patsfan55 - ADAM CARRIKER DE NEBRASKA 5
Bengals- patsfan55 - LAMAR WOODLEY LB MICHIGAN 3
Bengals- patsfan55 - TRAVAROUS BAIN CB HAMPTON 100
36

Bills- stinkypete - ANTONIO PITTMAN RB OHIO STATE 33
Bills- stinkypete - DAYMEION HUGHES CB CALIFORNIA 52
Bills- stinkypete - JACOBY JONES WR LANE 38
Bills- stinkypete - LAWRENCE TIMMONS LB FLORIDA STATE 3
Bills- stinkypete - TONY HUNT RB PENN ST 2
25.6

Broncos- ayjackson - DAVID CLOWNEY WR VIRGINIA TECH 71
Broncos- ayjackson - JAMES MARTEN OT BOSTON COLLEGE 3
Broncos- ayjackson - JUSTIN HARRELL DT TENNESSEE 5
Broncos- ayjackson - VICTOR ABIAMIRI DE NOTRE DAME 1
20

Browns- ironwasp - AARON ROSS CB TEXAS 16
Browns- ironwasp - BRADY QUINN QB NOTRE DAME 19
Browns- ironwasp - BRIAN LEONARD RB RUTGERS 15
Browns- ironwasp - MANNY RAMIREZ OG TEXAS TECH 14
16

Buccaneers- bakes781 - AARON ROUSE S VIRGINIA TECH 25
Buccaneers- bakes781 - ERIC WRIGHT CB UNLV 49
Buccaneers- bakes781 - JOE THOMAS OT WISCONSIN 1
Buccaneers- bakes781 - RUFUS ALEXANDER LB OKLAHOMA 108
Buccaneers- bakes781 - TANK TYLER DT NC STATE 47
46

Cardinals- primetime - GAINES ADAMS DE CLEMSON 1
Cardinals- primetime - H.B. BLADES LB PITTSBURGH 74
Cardinals- primetime - JUSTIN DURANT LB HAMPTON 21
Cardinals- primetime - TONY UGOH OT ARKANSAS 4
25

Chargers- sebman2112 - AUNDRAE ALLISON WR EAST CAROLINA 84
Chargers- sebman2112 - BRANDON FRYE OT VIRGINIA TECH 67
Chargers- sebman2112 - BRIAN ROBISON LB TEXAS 9
Chargers- sebman2112 - KOLBY SMITH RB LOUISVILLE 19
Chargers- sebman2112 - MICHAEL GRIFFIN S TEXAS 11
38

Chiefs- tampabaypats12 - DWAYNE JARRETT WR USC 22
Chiefs- tampabaypats12 - QUINN PIT**** DT OHIO ST 14
Chiefs- tampabaypats12 - RYAN HARRIS OT NOTRE DAME 16
17.33

Colts- gomezcat - CHANSI STUCKEY WR CLEMSON 95
Colts- gomezcat - COURTNEY BROWN CB CAL POLY 76
Colts- gomezcat - JON BEASON LB MIAMI 7
Colts- gomezcat - LORENZO BOOKER RB FLORIDA ST 24
Colts- gomezcat - XZAVIE JACKSON DE MISSOURI 150
70.4

Cowboys- Seymour93 - JASON HILL WR WASHINGTON STATE 23
Cowboys- Seymour93 - JOE STALEY OT CENTRAL MICHIGAN 6
Cowboys- Seymour93 - MARCUS THOMAS DT FLORIDA 1
Cowboys- Seymour93 - USAMA YOUNG CB KENT ST 21
12.75

Dolphins- VJCPatriot - DREW STANTON QB MICHIGAN STATE 17
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - LEVI BROWN OT PENN STATE 4
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - SIDNEY RICE WR SOUTH CAROLINA 4
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - TIM CROWDER DE TEXAS 15
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - YAMON FIGURS WR KANSAS ST 34
14.8

Eagles- Maroney39for6 - ROBERT MEACHEM WR TENNESSEE 1
Eagles- Maroney39for6 - TANARD JACKSON CB SYRACUSE 49
Eagles- Maroney39for6 - TIM SHAW OLB PENN ST 74
41.33

Falcons- SamBamsFan - AMOBI OKOYE DT LOUISVILLE 2
Falcons- SamBamsFan - ANTHONY SPENCER DE PURDUE 13
Falcons- SamBamsFan - ARRON SEARS OT TENNESSEE 9
Falcons- SamBamsFan - DESHAWN WYNN RB FLORIDA 95
Falcons- SamBamsFan - JOSH GATTIS S WAKE FOREST 75
Falcons- SamBamsFan - KENNY SCOTT CB GEORGIA TECH 100
Falcons- SamBamsFan - MIKE WALKER WR CENTRAL FLORIDA 42
48

Giants- Seneschal2 - CRAIG DAVIS WR LSU 21
Giants- Seneschal2 - MIKE OTTO OT PURDUE 107
Giants- Seneschal2 - PAUL POSLUSZNY LB PENN STATE 14
Giants- Seneschal2 - SABBY PISCITELLI S OREGON ST 17
39.75

Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - ERIC WEDDLE S UTAH 11
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - JAMAAL ANDERSON DE ARKANSAS 9
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - JOHN BECK QB BYU 73
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - QUINCY BLACK LB NEW MEXICO 11
26

Jets- Flying Fungi - DWAYNE BOWE WR LSU 2
Jets- Flying Fungi - JONATHAN WADE CB TENNESSEE 25
Jets- Flying Fungi - RAY MCDONALD DE FLORIDA 34
Jets- Flying Fungi - SAMSON SATELE OL HAWAII 29
22.5

Lions- PushnPencils - CALVIN JOHNSON WR GEORGIA TECH 0
Lions- PushnPencils - JARVIS MOSS DE FLORIDA 17
Lions- PushnPencils - MARSHALL YANDA OT IOWA 15
Lions- PushnPencils - TRENT EDWARDS QB STANFORD 26
14.5

Packers- skaIownsIyou - A.J. DAVIS CB NC STATE 7
Packers- skaIownsIyou - COURTNEY TAYLOR WR AUBURN 119
Packers- skaIownsIyou - MICHAEL BUSH RB LOUISVILLE 53
Packers- skaIownsIyou - REGGIE NELSON S FLORIDA 5
46

Panthers- ice - BRANDON MERIWEATHER S MIAMI 21
Panthers- ice - BUSTER DAVIS ILB FLORIDA ST 14
Panthers- ice - GREG OLSEN TE MIAMI 17
Panthers- ice - RHEMA MCKNIGHT WR NOTRE DAME 100
38

Patriots- mavfan2390 - MARCUS MCCAULEY CB FRESNO STATE 44
Patriots- mavfan2390 - MARSHAWN LYNCH RB CALIFORNIA 12
Patriots- mavfan2390 - MARVIN WHITE S TCU 13
Patriots- mavfan2390 - STEWART BRADLEY OLB NEBRASKA 4
18.25

Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - JAMARCUS RUSSELL QB LSU 0
Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - KENNY IRONS RB AUBURN 50
Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - QUENTIN MOSES DE GEORGIA 0
Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - RYAN KALIL C USC 26
Raiders- SeanBruschi54- DAVID IRONS CB AUBURN 94
34

Rams- broadwayjoe - BRANDON MEBANE DT CALIFORNIA 3
Rams- broadwayjoe - DARRELLE REVIS CB PITTSBURGH 1
Rams- broadwayjoe - DAVID HARRIS LB MICHIGAN 5
Rams- broadwayjoe - JAY MOORE DE NEBRASKA 13
5.5

Ravens- Handel - CHARLES JOHNSON DE GEORGIA 22
Ravens- Handel - JUSTIN BLALOCK OG TEXAS 10
Ravens- Handel - PAUL WILLIAMS WR FRESNO ST 54
Ravens- Handel - TROY SMITH QB OHIO ST 37
30.75

Redskins- Maroney TD - LARON LANDRY S LSU 0
0

Saints- zarakotas5 - ANDY ALLEMAN OG AKRON 0
Saints- zarakotas5 - ANTWAN BARNES LB FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL 11
Saints- zarakotas5 - CHRIS DAVIS WR FLORIDA ST 3
Saints- zarakotas5 - CHRIS HOUSTON CB ARKANSAS 14
Saints- zarakotas5 - ERIC FRAMPTON S WASHINGTON ST 39
Saints- zarakotas5 - IKAIKA ALAMA-FRANCIS DE HAWAII 0
11.17

Seahawks- bakes781 - KEVIN KOLB QB HOUSTON 84
Seahawks- bakes781 - PAUL SOLIAI DT UTAH 23
Seahawks- bakes781 - ZACH MILLER TE ARIZONA STATE 17
41.33

Steelers- jct - ADAM KOETS OT OREGON ST 70
Steelers- jct - ALAN BRANCH DT MICHIGAN 18
Steelers- jct - BRANDON SILER LB FLORIDA 194
Steelers- jct - DALLAS BAKER WR FLORIDA 95
Steelers- jct - DAN BAZUIN DE CENTRAL MICHIGAN 15
78.4

Texans- A.C. Vegas - DOUG FREE OT NORTHERN ILLINOIS 49
Texans- A.C. Vegas - J.L. HIGGINS WR UTEP 8
Texans- A.C. Vegas - LEON HALL CB MICHIGAN 8
21.67

Titans- Patskers - BRANDON JACKSON RB NEBRASKA 17
Titans- Patskers - FRED BENNETT CB SOUTH CAROLINA 8
Titans- Patskers - JON ABBATE LB WAKE FOREST 100
Titans- Patskers - JOSH WILSON CB MARYLAND 5
Titans- Patskers - TED GINN JR WR OHIO STATE 10
28

Vikings- broadwayjoe - ADRIAN PETERSON RB OKLAHOMA 0
Vikings- broadwayjoe - JOSH BEEKMAN OG BOSTON COLLEGE 58
Vikings- broadwayjoe - STEVE SMITH WR USC 10
Vikings- broadwayjoe - TARELL BROWN CB TEXAS 41
27.25

After getting a chance to look over Bakes results I wanted to send out congrats to SeanBruschi and Zarakota for getting a couple of their picks in the draft right on the button thats pretty darn good.

 

[bakes781]

After getting a chance to look over Bakes results I wanted to send out congrats to SeanBruschi and Zarakota for getting a couple of their picks in the draft right on the button thats pretty darn good.

overall though you did the best with a score of 5.5. I disregard the Redskins since they only had 1 pick.

 

[gomezcat]

I feel safe at this point knowing that Xzavie Jackson was Box's pick. Should he end up as a Hall of Famer, I will of course be pointing out that Box picked him with my permission.

I think the true test of the draft will be to see how these guys pan out over x years.

 

[zarakotas5]

Thanks for the recognition, broadwayjoe. But, for realism, you take the cake. Of course, picking in the fourth is harder than picking in the first, etc...
It'd be curious to see who really had the "best" draft in a few...

As far as talent/realism goes for now, who I like (may forget a couple)...

SF: Lots of picks helps, but lots of talent. Most improved team?

DEN: Very accurate to real life draft slots overall, except Clowney. But...Clowney might be really good.

CLE: Good overall infusion.

DAL: Give 'em three years to see how it shakes out.

CAR: Took my targets 3 out of 4 times. Within reach, too.

STL: Very close to real life on all rounds.

Y'know: Dolphins, too. Looking back, it may have seems a lil' questionable but now seems pretty solid and very accurate. Jags, Lions, and Pats very honorable mention.

 

[VJCPatriot]

How did you come up with these figures Bake? I am assuming you are trying to score here based on how close the GM drafted compared to the actual team's draft rather than value per pick right? And I'm going to assume that lower is better... because the Bears reach for Ben Patrick in Round 1 has gotta hurt.

However I don't think that's the acurate way to calculate who did best so here is how it breaks down under mine:

49ers- dryheat44 - ALLEN BARBRE OT MISSOURI SOUTHERN 9
49ers- dryheat44 - ANTHONY GONZALEZ WR OHIO STATE 10
49ers- dryheat44 - ANTONIO JOHNSON DE MISSISSIPPI ST 76
49ers- dryheat44 - BRANDON HARRISON S STANFORD 20
49ers- dryheat44 - DARIUS WALKER RB NOTRE DAME 100
49ers- dryheat44 - JOHN WENDLING S WYOMING 80
49ers- dryheat44 - PATRICK WILLIS LB MISSISSIPPI 0
49ers- dryheat44 - ZAK DEOSSIE LB BROWN 19
39.25

Bears- chunkypony - ANTHONY WATERS LB CLEMSON 2
Bears- chunkypony - BEN GRUBBS OG AUBURN 8
Bears- chunkypony - BEN PATRICK TE DELAWARE 184
Bears- chunkypony - JORDAN PALMER QB UTEP 75
67.25

Bengals- patsfan55 - ADAM CARRIKER DE NEBRASKA 5
Bengals- patsfan55 - LAMAR WOODLEY LB MICHIGAN 3
Bengals- patsfan55 - TRAVAROUS BAIN CB HAMPTON 100
36

Bills- stinkypete - ANTONIO PITTMAN RB OHIO STATE 33
Bills- stinkypete - DAYMEION HUGHES CB CALIFORNIA 52
Bills- stinkypete - JACOBY JONES WR LANE 38
Bills- stinkypete - LAWRENCE TIMMONS LB FLORIDA STATE 3
Bills- stinkypete - TONY HUNT RB PENN ST 2
25.6

Broncos- ayjackson - DAVID CLOWNEY WR VIRGINIA TECH 71
Broncos- ayjackson - JAMES MARTEN OT BOSTON COLLEGE 3
Broncos- ayjackson - JUSTIN HARRELL DT TENNESSEE 5
Broncos- ayjackson - VICTOR ABIAMIRI DE NOTRE DAME 1
20

Browns- ironwasp - AARON ROSS CB TEXAS 16
Browns- ironwasp - BRADY QUINN QB NOTRE DAME 19
Browns- ironwasp - BRIAN LEONARD RB RUTGERS 15
Browns- ironwasp - MANNY RAMIREZ OG TEXAS TECH 14
16

Buccaneers- bakes781 - AARON ROUSE S VIRGINIA TECH 25
Buccaneers- bakes781 - ERIC WRIGHT CB UNLV 49
Buccaneers- bakes781 - JOE THOMAS OT WISCONSIN 1
Buccaneers- bakes781 - RUFUS ALEXANDER LB OKLAHOMA 108
Buccaneers- bakes781 - TANK TYLER DT NC STATE 47
46

Cardinals- primetime - GAINES ADAMS DE CLEMSON 1
Cardinals- primetime - H.B. BLADES LB PITTSBURGH 74
Cardinals- primetime - JUSTIN DURANT LB HAMPTON 21
Cardinals- primetime - TONY UGOH OT ARKANSAS 4
25

Chargers- sebman2112 - AUNDRAE ALLISON WR EAST CAROLINA 84
Chargers- sebman2112 - BRANDON FRYE OT VIRGINIA TECH 67
Chargers- sebman2112 - BRIAN ROBISON LB TEXAS 9
Chargers- sebman2112 - KOLBY SMITH RB LOUISVILLE 19
Chargers- sebman2112 - MICHAEL GRIFFIN S TEXAS 11
38

Chiefs- tampabaypats12 - DWAYNE JARRETT WR USC 22
Chiefs- tampabaypats12 - QUINN PIT**** DT OHIO ST 14
Chiefs- tampabaypats12 - RYAN HARRIS OT NOTRE DAME 16
17.33

Colts- gomezcat - CHANSI STUCKEY WR CLEMSON 95
Colts- gomezcat - COURTNEY BROWN CB CAL POLY 76
Colts- gomezcat - JON BEASON LB MIAMI 7
Colts- gomezcat - LORENZO BOOKER RB FLORIDA ST 24
Colts- gomezcat - XZAVIE JACKSON DE MISSOURI 150
70.4

Cowboys- Seymour93 - JASON HILL WR WASHINGTON STATE 23
Cowboys- Seymour93 - JOE STALEY OT CENTRAL MICHIGAN 6
Cowboys- Seymour93 - MARCUS THOMAS DT FLORIDA 1
Cowboys- Seymour93 - USAMA YOUNG CB KENT ST 21
12.75

Dolphins- VJCPatriot - DREW STANTON QB MICHIGAN STATE 17
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - LEVI BROWN OT PENN STATE 4
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - SIDNEY RICE WR SOUTH CAROLINA 4
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - TIM CROWDER DE TEXAS 15
Dolphins- VJCPatriot - YAMON FIGURS WR KANSAS ST 34
14.8

Eagles- Maroney39for6 - ROBERT MEACHEM WR TENNESSEE 1
Eagles- Maroney39for6 - TANARD JACKSON CB SYRACUSE 49
Eagles- Maroney39for6 - TIM SHAW OLB PENN ST 74
41.33

Falcons- SamBamsFan - AMOBI OKOYE DT LOUISVILLE 2
Falcons- SamBamsFan - ANTHONY SPENCER DE PURDUE 13
Falcons- SamBamsFan - ARRON SEARS OT TENNESSEE 9
Falcons- SamBamsFan - DESHAWN WYNN RB FLORIDA 95
Falcons- SamBamsFan - JOSH GATTIS S WAKE FOREST 75
Falcons- SamBamsFan - KENNY SCOTT CB GEORGIA TECH 100
Falcons- SamBamsFan - MIKE WALKER WR CENTRAL FLORIDA 42
48

Giants- Seneschal2 - CRAIG DAVIS WR LSU 21
Giants- Seneschal2 - MIKE OTTO OT PURDUE 107
Giants- Seneschal2 - PAUL POSLUSZNY LB PENN STATE 14
Giants- Seneschal2 - SABBY PISCITELLI S OREGON ST 17
39.75

Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - ERIC WEDDLE S UTAH 11
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - JAMAAL ANDERSON DE ARKANSAS 9
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - JOHN BECK QB BYU 73
Jaguars- Irish Hooligan - QUINCY BLACK LB NEW MEXICO 11
26

Jets- Flying Fungi - DWAYNE BOWE WR LSU 2
Jets- Flying Fungi - JONATHAN WADE CB TENNESSEE 25
Jets- Flying Fungi - RAY MCDONALD DE FLORIDA 34
Jets- Flying Fungi - SAMSON SATELE OL HAWAII 29
22.5

Lions- PushnPencils - CALVIN JOHNSON WR GEORGIA TECH 0
Lions- PushnPencils - JARVIS MOSS DE FLORIDA 17
Lions- PushnPencils - MARSHALL YANDA OT IOWA 15
Lions- PushnPencils - TRENT EDWARDS QB STANFORD 26
14.5

Packers- skaIownsIyou - A.J. DAVIS CB NC STATE 7
Packers- skaIownsIyou - COURTNEY TAYLOR WR AUBURN 119
Packers- skaIownsIyou - MICHAEL BUSH RB LOUISVILLE 53
Packers- skaIownsIyou - REGGIE NELSON S FLORIDA 5
46

Panthers- ice - BRANDON MERIWEATHER S MIAMI 21
Panthers- ice - BUSTER DAVIS ILB FLORIDA ST 14
Panthers- ice - GREG OLSEN TE MIAMI 17
Panthers- ice - RHEMA MCKNIGHT WR NOTRE DAME 100
38

Patriots- mavfan2390 - MARCUS MCCAULEY CB FRESNO STATE 44
Patriots- mavfan2390 - MARSHAWN LYNCH RB CALIFORNIA 12
Patriots- mavfan2390 - MARVIN WHITE S TCU 13
Patriots- mavfan2390 - STEWART BRADLEY OLB NEBRASKA 4
18.25

Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - JAMARCUS RUSSELL QB LSU 0
Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - KENNY IRONS RB AUBURN 50
Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - QUENTIN MOSES DE GEORGIA 0
Raiders- SeanBruschi54 - RYAN KALIL C USC 26
Raiders- SeanBruschi54- DAVID IRONS CB AUBURN 94
34

Rams- broadwayjoe - BRANDON MEBANE DT CALIFORNIA 3
Rams- broadwayjoe - DARRELLE REVIS CB PITTSBURGH 1
Rams- broadwayjoe - DAVID HARRIS LB MICHIGAN 5
Rams- broadwayjoe - JAY MOORE DE NEBRASKA 13
5.5

Ravens- Handel - CHARLES JOHNSON DE GEORGIA 22
Ravens- Handel - JUSTIN BLALOCK OG TEXAS 10
Ravens- Handel - PAUL WILLIAMS WR FRESNO ST 54
Ravens- Handel - TROY SMITH QB OHIO ST 37
30.75

Redskins- Maroney TD - LARON LANDRY S LSU 0
0

Saints- zarakotas5 - ANDY ALLEMAN OG AKRON 0
Saints- zarakotas5 - ANTWAN BARNES LB FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL 11
Saints- zarakotas5 - CHRIS DAVIS WR FLORIDA ST 3
Saints- zarakotas5 - CHRIS HOUSTON CB ARKANSAS 14
Saints- zarakotas5 - ERIC FRAMPTON S WASHINGTON ST 39
Saints- zarakotas5 - IKAIKA ALAMA-FRANCIS DE HAWAII 0
11.17

Seahawks- bakes781 - KEVIN KOLB QB HOUSTON 84
Seahawks- bakes781 - PAUL SOLIAI DT UTAH 23
Seahawks- bakes781 - ZACH MILLER TE ARIZONA STATE 17
41.33

Steelers- jct - ADAM KOETS OT OREGON ST 70
Steelers- jct - ALAN BRANCH DT MICHIGAN 18
Steelers- jct - BRANDON SILER LB FLORIDA 194
Steelers- jct - DALLAS BAKER WR FLORIDA 95
Steelers- jct - DAN BAZUIN DE CENTRAL MICHIGAN 15
78.4

Texans- A.C. Vegas - DOUG FREE OT NORTHERN ILLINOIS 49
Texans- A.C. Vegas - J.L. HIGGINS WR UTEP 8
Texans- A.C. Vegas - LEON HALL CB MICHIGAN 8
21.67

Titans- Patskers - BRANDON JACKSON RB NEBRASKA 17
Titans- Patskers - FRED BENNETT CB SOUTH CAROLINA 8
Titans- Patskers - JON ABBATE LB WAKE FOREST 100
Titans- Patskers - JOSH WILSON CB MARYLAND 5
Titans- Patskers - TED GINN JR WR OHIO STATE 10
28

Vikings- broadwayjoe - ADRIAN PETERSON RB OKLAHOMA 0
Vikings- broadwayjoe - JOSH BEEKMAN OG BOSTON COLLEGE 58
Vikings- broadwayjoe - STEVE SMITH WR USC 10
Vikings- broadwayjoe - TARELL BROWN CB TEXAS 41
27.25

 

[bakes781]

How did you come up with these figures Bake? I am assuming you are trying to score here based on how close the GM drafted compared to the actual team's draft rather than value per pick right? And I'm going to assume that lower is better... because the Bears reach for Ben Patrick in Round 1 has gotta hurt.

Right. I mean who's to really say where a selection should have been made? I picked Kevin Kolb in the 4th round, but a lot of people felt Philly reached badly on that selection in the 2nd.