And now you're doing it...
Luck took over a 2 win team. In his 3 years since:
3 11-5 seasons
2 Division titles
3 playoff appearances
3 playoff wins
2 postseasons with at least 1 win
That's a damn fine start to his career.
What some of you are doing is just a riff on the "But Montana never lost a Super Bowl" argument.....
Well, yeah, but that's because he was losing earlier in the playoffs. Yeah, Luck got steamrolled by the Patriots last year in the AFCCG, but he made it to the AFCCG. And he did it with Trent Richardson as his RB, and that defense that people here treat as a running joke.
That would be ridiculous. He's a top 3-10 talent (I'm not about to argue slotting, so I'll toss in a wide range), so why on Earth would we be foolish enough to consider him as flawed as most QBs in the league?
And I don't know where you're getting this 'aura' thing from. You're starting to sound like Woolster on this issue, and that's not a good thing, at all.