- Joined
- Aug 13, 2005
- Messages
- 19,365
- Reaction score
- 13,049
Neither one; Jeff George wins that honor.Who do we think is more physically talented? Brady or Manning?
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.Neither one; Jeff George wins that honor.Who do we think is more physically talented? Brady or Manning?
Neither one; Jeff George wins that honor.
Neither one; Jeff George wins that honor.
This has been a pretty strong debate and got me thinking. There are 10 QBs with 2 rings or more... how do you rank them? I have them ordered like this, but most importantly I have Brady at 2 behind Montana.
My Pittsburgh in-laws think Bradshaw can't be any lower than 2 since he is 4-0. Thoughts?
My thoughts:
Terry Bradshaw 1st Superbowl appearance QB Rating 108.0
Tom Brady 1st Superbowl appearance QB Rating 86.2
Joe Montana 1st Superbowl appearance QB Rating 100.0
Terry Bradshaw 2nd Superbowl appearance QB Rating 122.5
Tom Brady 2nd Superbowl appearance QB Rating 100.5
Joe Montana 2nd Superbowl appearance QB Rating 127.2
Terry Bradshaw 3rd Superbowl appearance QB Rating 119.2
Tom Brady 3rd Superbowl appearance QB Rating 110.2
Joe Montana 3rd Superbowl appearance QB Rating 115.2
Terry Bradshaw 4th Superbowl appearance QB Rating 101.9
Tom Brady 4th Superbowl appearance QB Rating 82.5
Joe Montana 4th Superbowl appearance QB Rating 147.6
Who’s the best of those three in Big Games?
Montana is #1. Bradshaw is #2.
Very nice well thought out retort. Clutch performances can be considered different than "best in big games" I'll give you that one. But I still like my man Terry over everyone else cause I'm a blind Homer lol.
I remember Brady's drive against the Rams, I was pulling for the Pats that year cause I hated the Rams and am an AFC first kind of guy most of the time. It was a great game.
I will admit to being a homer. In fact, I think a lot of fans are... so sue us. Maybe my ranking of Brady over Bradshaw is premature, but this is my problem.
When the Steelers fans talk about how great the 70s teams were it Jack Lambert and Mean Joe and Jack Ham and Franco Harris that get brought up. Bradshaw is a sidebar to the whole thing.
Maybe it is an undeserved knock. Maybe it's because I never got to see him play. Thinking back, I probably should have ranked Elway behind Bradshaw, but I think there is little doubt that Brady and Elway each were the reason that their teams were able to pull out the big wins. You can't say that about Bradshaw.