PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans
  • NEWS ▼
  • FORUM ▼
  • SCHEDULE
  • NFL ▼
  • STATS ▼
  • GAMES ▼
LOGIN | REGISTER
PatsFans.com › Patriots Blog › Ian Logue › Brady No Longer Great in The Playoffs?
Ian Logue

Brady No Longer Great in The Playoffs?

Ian Logue
Ian Logue Senior Writer · PatsFans.com since 2000
August 18, 2010  · 10:41 pm | 4 min read | @IanLogue
Follow PatsFans.com
Google News ✉ Newsletter

If at first you don't succeed, why not try a different tactic.

Patriots fans, Brady is no longer a playoff calibur quarterback.

Yes, you've read that correctly, and go tell your friends what you've heard, because the numbers back up this argument. I heard it on the radio and it must be true, so it's time to start the movement to running that pesky 2-Time Super Bowl MVP out of town.

And I'm jumping on board. I'm throwing out my three Super Bowl Championship T-Shirts because I've been wearing the same ones now for six years, and that's just not good enough any more. There hasn't been a "hat and T-Shirt game" that's given me a new one with a Lombardi trophy on it in so long that it's getting to the point where apparently the loyalty - just like the T-Shirt - should be fading along with it.

Not really - but that appears to be the reaction that is attempting to be created.

The ongoing Tom Brady contract situation has caused plenty of controversy over the past few months, with it first being reported by national media outlets who tried to suggest a rift between the Patriots signal caller and owner Robert Kraft. Following those stories local media members also jumped on board, up until recently when news came out from ESPN's Adam Schefter that both Brady and New England were making progress toward a deal. Shortly after that came a golf outing between Brady and Kraft - which further quieted the discussion.

Well, since that vehicle of negativity has sailed, it appears another has been placed in the water.


It may be time to move on from Tom Brady, after the Patriots signal caller is now just a mere 4-4 in his last eight playoff games.
Michael Felger of 98.5 The Sports Hub spent Wednesday afternoon focusing on New England's playoff struggles in recent years, continually harping on the fact that Brady is a mere 4-4 in his last eight playoff games. While most fans called in trying to point out that he was coming back from reconstructive knee surgery, Felger was pointing out the highs from last season and saying that, "the knee didn't seem to be bothering him then."

Although no mention of the broken ribs or the broken finger, or other things that could have played a factor in what was still a season that plenty of other QB's could only dream of having.

In other words, if you can't win the argument one way, why not see if you can spin the story another. Why not see if you can't potentially get a following of Brady criticizers who start disecting every negative play he makes, while ignoring the positives.

We've seen it before here in Boston with other writers, and it appears this is what's on deck now. After all, with Brady in the final year of his contract and not yet re-signed long term to this point, the chance is still there to try and make him miserable enough that maybe he'll decide should the dollar amount he's offered not be high enough, maybe he'll decide it's time to move on.

After all, Brady did mention recently that "even guys like Joe Montana didn't finish his career in San Francisco", so why should he be any different? Should this movement continue, you can expect that clip to be replayed quite a bit.

In Felger's self proclaimed attempt to be "fair" he felt that with all the Brett Favre nonsense in the last 24 hours if we're going to criticize Favre's playoff performances, Brady deserves to be included in the discussion.

Wow, apparently I've been watching a different quarterback and football team all these years.

Statistics are a wonderful thing to use when you want to spin them to fit your argument. You'll have to forgive me while I throw out what's written on paper and simply believe what my eyes have actually seen. All I know is that Brady is 14-4 as a starter in the postseason with three Super Bowl rings, and hasn't shown me any reason to believe he's done with keeping the Patriots in contention for a championship.

Myself, hey, I've enjoyed the 14 wins and three Super Bowl Championships. I've enjoyed accumulating some Championship apparel and some photos that captured great moments in this team's history which now irritate my wife as they hang on our walls. As for the four postseason games that were lost, only one deeply disappointed me - and anyone who watched that game knows that it's hard to blame Brady entirely for that one.

While Felger starts beating the drum to see if he can get the march toward beating Brady out of town, hopefully most rational fans will look back and break down each of those postseason losses and realize that in each of the four games they've lost, Brady wasn't the reason. After all, on those days where he wasn't "great", he was at least "good", which is more than you can say for a certain guy who has made a name for himself in making critical playoff turnovers.

Mere months ago after Peyton Manning threw an interception that was returned for a touchdown that ultimately cost his team the football game, most were saying Brady may now be the best ever. How times have changed in just a short period of time.

Needless to say every time I think I've heard it all, something happens to change my mind.

Unfortunately today was one of those days.

This is an archived article originally published on August 18, 2010. Content reflects the editorial context of its original publication date.

More News Headlines:

MORSE: Patriots Positional Analysis – Secondary

MORSE: Patriots Positional Analysis – Secondary

By: Mark Morse
Patriots positional analysis breaks down the 'best in the league' secondary, detailing Christian Gonzalez's contract, Marcus Jones's role, and Kevin Byard's 2026 impact.
51 minutes ago
Patriots News 07-12, Pre-Training Camp 53-Man Roster Projection

Patriots News 07-12, Pre-Training Camp 53-Man Roster Projection

By: Steve Balestrieri
Previewing the Patriots' pre-training camp 53-man roster projection, Christian Gonzalez, Sean Payton's Belichick offer, and Mac Jones' 2022 season.
2 days ago
MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis – Linebackers and Special Teams

MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis – Linebackers and Special Teams

By: Mark Morse
Patriots' Linebackers and Special Teams are analyzed, detailing player performances, contract years, and improvement areas for multiple players.
4 days ago
MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis: Defensive Line

MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis: Defensive Line

By: Mark Morse
Analyzing the Patriots' defensive line ahead of training camp, breaking down established veterans and promising young talent at defensive tackle and EDGE.
1 week ago
Patriots News 07-05, Positions That Still Need More Depth

Patriots News 07-05, Positions That Still Need More Depth

By: Steve Balestrieri
Previewing Patriots news for July 5th, this report details critical depth needs at tight end, off-ball linebacker, and edge as training camp nears.
1 week ago

📈 Recent Most-Read Articles:
1
2022 New England Patriots Draft Picks – Full List
2
2024 Patriots Draft Picks – FULL LIST
3
Patriots Announce Ticket Increase, Dropping Stadium Parking Fees
4
Tom Brady’s ‘Life Is Hard’ Speech: Full Patriots HOF Transcript
5
Heading Into Free Agency, Patriots Have Two Tough Player Decisions to Make

📅 This Week in Patriots History:

From our archive - this week all-time:
June 29 - July 14 (Through 26yrs)

  • Tuesday Patriots Headlines - July 13th(2010)
  • Patriots Players on the Bubble Prior to 2019 Training Camp(2019)
  • Bruschi Holds Camp(2009)
  • Patriots News 6/30: Key Year For Maye, No Plans For Kraft to Sell(2025)
  • Wednesday Patriots Headlines - June 30th(2010)
  • Relax Sox Fans; Patriots Are On Tap(2004)
FULL ARCHIVE
Right Now At PatsFans.com:
MORSE: Patriots Positional Analysis - Secondary
2026 NFL Offseason:
MORSE: Patriots Positional Analysis - Secondary
By: Mark Morse
  • Patriots News 07-12, Pre-Training Camp 53-Man Roster Projection
  • MORSE: Patriots Position Analysis - Linebackers and Special Teams
Free Newsletter

BE THE FIRST TO KNOW

Join 2,000+ fans getting exclusive stats, analysis, and insights delivered straight to their inbox every week. Never miss a play.

📊
Weekly Stats Deep-dive analysis
🎯
First Access New features & tools
📤
Breaking News Player Signings & Rumors

Subscribe Now

* required

Intuit Mailchimp

PatsFans.com Social Logo
PATSFANS.com

The longest-running independent New England Patriots site online since 2000. Not affiliated w/any school, team or league.

Resources

  • Patriots Forum
  • Schedule
  • Patriots Roster
  • Transcripts
  • Patriots Wiki Pages
  • Archive

Stats

  • Offensive Stats
  • Opponent Stats
  • Offensive Line
  • Snaps Overview
  • Penalties

Analysis

  • Snap Analysis
  • Personnel Groupings
  • Stats By Personnel
  • Top 10 Plays
  • Offensive Line
  • Defensive Totals

Site

  • About Us
  • Podcast
  • Newsletter
  • Contact Us

© 2000-2026 PatsFans.com

Privacy Policy Advertise RSS Feed