Difficult to compile an all-time list, and really pointless because so many fans are too recent to appreciate one. But I'll make a pass at a Belichick era list, about which most everyone can comparatively opine:
(1) Brady
(2) Harrison
(3) Faulk
(4) Bruschi
(5) Brown
...but I suspect in 5 years my list will be:
(1) Brady
(2) Harrison
(3) Moss
(4) Mayo
(5) Welker
(1) Brady
(2) Harrison
(3) Faulk
(4) Bruschi
(5) Brown
...but I suspect in 5 years my list will be:
(1) Brady
(2) Harrison
(3) Moss
(4) Mayo
(5) Welker