primetime
Pro Bowl Player
- Joined
- Jun 15, 2005
- Messages
- 13,627
- Reaction score
- 15,375
Okay offense seems set but I am looking to add 1-2 DL and maybe 1 LB.
Bobby Hamilton should be in there. There are some fringe guys - Seau, maybe Mike Wright. I'd obviously include Ted Washington but if we're leaving off 1 year players than he can't be in (along with Revis and Waters, the two other guys I'd include).
Green-Ellis for Smith? No way. Smith has 2 rings and was a MAJOR part of the first. 2001 was the best season a BB RB has ever had here. And I was a huge Smith critic, but he did what he did. In th eyears BJGE played for the Pats they were 2-4 in the postseason.
Vereen is in in my book because of his play in the SB.
Revis was out of the argument in the OP because he excluded 1 year players.
Yeah, that's probably fair. Smith wasn't great, but he was good enough in those Super Bowl runs. I just don't think Vereen was all that great, Super Bowl notwithstanding, especially compared to Woodhead.