If we would of kept Ty Law around for 06/07

Do you think the outcome for those seasons would been different?

I think so because in the '06 ACC title game we only lost by a few points maybe if ty law was on our D he could of prevented at least one of the colts touchdowns or maybe even get a pick, same with SB42 we only lost by a few points maybe if Ty Law was on that D maybe the giants score one less TD or gets a valuable pick. Didn't mention '05 because I don't think it would of made much of a difference on the outcome of the season

Would of, could of, should of ...

I would think Law would have done a better job against Burress than Hobbs.

Mike the Brit said:

Would of, could of, should of ...

Click to expand...

You can't 'of' your Law and 'have' him too.

That season was such a mess with injuries to DB's. Who were are starters by the end of the year? I honestly have no idea. Deshea Townsend? Hank Poteat? Gay? Deltha O'Neal? It's all a blur of JAG DB's from that era.

turkeyneck said:

You can't 'of' your Law and 'have' him too.

Click to expand...

Have course not!

203Pat said:

That season was such a mess with injuries to DB's. Who were are starters by the end of the year? I honestly have no idea. Deshea Townsend? Hank Poteat? Gay? Deltha O'Neal? It's all a blur of JAG DB's from that era.

Click to expand...

Are you talking '06 cause I wouldn't call that season a mess considering how close we were to winning another SB

Bradyking12 said:

Are you talking '06 cause I wouldn't call that season a mess considering how close we were to winning another SB

Click to expand...

Talking injuries to our DB's that year being a mess. Didn't we end up with 5 or 6 DB's on IR that year?

flasox27 said:

I would think Law would have done a better job against Burress than Hobbs.

Click to expand...

That hurts soo much to think about

Mike the Brit said:

Would of, could of, should of ...

Click to expand...

Grammar police make another arrest!

Mack Herron said:

Grammar police make another arrest!

Click to expand...

Yup: either learn to write accurately or don't start threads -- thread titles with elementary mistakes in them are an embarrassment.

Mike the Brit said:

Yup: either learn to write accurately or don't start threads -- thread titles with elementary mistakes in them are an embarrassment.

Click to expand...

Embarassment is insufficient it appears. We need harsher penalties. Like having to watch the Jets.

I don't understand what's going on. Asking if they should have "kept" him in 2006 implies that that they also would have kept him in 2005. They were absurdly close to the cap in both of those years, so you'd have to make a whole bunch of other moves for it to work. This is the kind of hypothetical that you can't come close to fully explaining in a 100 word post.

how would the team have looked different if Law was kept? you cant just add, you'd have to take away something because at least one other or multiple other moves/players wouldnt happen

Mack Herron said:

Embarassment is insufficient it appears. We need harsher penalties. Like having to watch the Jets.

Click to expand...

I think the problem may come from reading Jets' message boards ...

Sciz said:

I don't understand what's going on. Asking if they should have "kept" him in 2006 implies that that they also would have kept him in 2005. They were absurdly close to the cap in both of those years, so you'd have to make a whole bunch of other moves for it to work. This is the kind of hypothetical that you can't come close to fully explaining in a 100 word post.

Click to expand...

He could of took a pay cut.....

Bradyking12 said:

He could of took a pay cut.....

Click to expand...

They had less than $1 of cap room by the end of the 2006 season. You'd have to make multiple cuts each year to keep Law, regardless of how much of a discount you think he would have taken.

Bradyking12 said:

He could of took a pay cut.....

Click to expand...

There's a term Ty never heard of.

Bradyking12 said:

He could of took a pay cut.....

Click to expand...

So, now the thread is, should Ty Law have played for vet minimum? I say yes. Let his kids eat Ramen noodles.

flasox27 said:

I would think Law would have done a better job against Burress than Hobbs.

Click to expand...

When Tyree had his miracle "helmet catch" at what...the 58th minute of the game, Plax had 8 targets for 1 catch and 13 yards. I know he caught the 14 yd TD, but you are mis-remembering.