PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans

Refereeing Grade: B +


Status
Not open for further replies.
Yip refs were great! A couple missed calls on either side but a great overall effort!
 
The refs let them play for the most part. A lot of us around here were worried that some phantom call was going to change the game, and that didn't happen. So kudos to them.
 
Great? No. They were not great. Saying so is just ridiculous.
They screwed the replay review of Amendola's catch. The CBS Replay clearly showed Amendola with control and his knee down on the ground while in contact with the Denver Safety.

They didn't call the egregious holding of Gronk by Talib in the end zone that kept Gronk from going up and getting a TD.

They didn't call Ward for his hold on Gronk.

They didn't call the numerous hands to the face by the Denver D that helped push Kline back on several occasions.
 
Great? No. They were not great. Saying so is just ridiculous.
They screwed the replay review of Amendola's catch. The CBS Replay clearly showed Amendola with control and his knee down on the ground while in contact with the Denver Safety.

They didn't call the egregious holding of Gronk by Talib in the end zone that kept Gronk from going up and getting a TD.

They didn't call Ward for his hold on Gronk.

They didn't call the numerous hands to the face by the Denver D that helped push Kline back on several occasions.

They also didn't railroad the them as I expected. The Patriots didn't play well enough to win today. I'm not going to lay this one at the feet of the refs.
 
Great? No. They were not great. Saying so is just ridiculous.
They screwed the replay review of Amendola's catch. The CBS Replay clearly showed Amendola with control and his knee down on the ground while in contact with the Denver Safety.

They didn't call the egregious holding of Gronk by Talib in the end zone that kept Gronk from going up and getting a TD.

They didn't call Ward for his hold on Gronk.

They didn't call the numerous hands to the face by the Denver D that helped push Kline back on several occasions.

They also overturned the backwards pass that led to our score and called unnecessary roughness/holding several times. They were about as good as we could have hoped for. Unfortunately you couldn't say that about our OL.
 
C at best, probably a D. If they just spotted the ball and didn't call any penalties it would've been an improvement. If that's a B+...

That said the Patriots lost on their own.
 
Not great, but a lot better than I expected. B+ is on the money.
 
On a sliding scale of "totally ****ing NE" as some expected I'd give them an A honestly. They get t a couple tough/obscure calls in our favor correct that kept it a game.

Whatever grade you give them, they were NOT to blame for the loss. Did not change outcome. Our offense did that.
 
The refs let them play for the most part. A lot of us around here were worried that some phantom call was going to change the game, and that didn't happen. So kudos to them.

It did kill a couple early drives though. The PI that was uncalled on Gronk early was one.

Late in the game, you can't always get a call but James White was interfered with badly.

Regardless, Brady had his worst game of the season, and one of the worst ever by him. He had Gronk in the end zone on the 2 point conversion.

That being said, the Patriots are sorely in need of an outside WR. Brady's throws to White were perfect, except for the interception, but you can't expect a RB to go up and get the ball.
 
Great? No. They were not great. Saying so is just ridiculous.
They screwed the replay review of Amendola's catch. The CBS Replay clearly showed Amendola with control and his knee down on the ground while in contact with the Denver Safety.

They didn't call the egregious holding of Gronk by Talib in the end zone that kept Gronk from going up and getting a TD.

They didn't call Ward for his hold on Gronk.

They didn't call the numerous hands to the face by the Denver D that helped push Kline back on several occasions.
They didn't call Brady for intentional grounding once when at least three times they could have.. Twice in the final drive..

The officials let them play..
 
SCUMSLIME SPAMMY!!!

we all KNEW you'd be here to spam the board with your scum, scummy...SCUM IT UP SCUMSLIME!!
 
I thought the refs were reasonable. Outside of a few non-calls either way, for a game played in Denver, I'm not going to complain about their performance.
 
hochuli had a decent day today.

denver remains undefeated when he refs lol
 
Was Ryan roughed up on one of his punts ?
They never showed a replay of it.
 
The Amendola call alone made the difference in the game. If it had been correctly called, we would have had a first and goal; as it turned out we lost the ball on downs.

There was a replay shown at one point in the second half of a play on which a false start was called against the Patriots, and the OL they called it on did not so much as twitch. They called at least three false starts on us in the course of the game; the one on Gronkowski was legitimate; at least one other one was as corrupt and phantom as a call can ever be, and it was in the red zone in the second half.

The PI called on the Patriots in the first quarter kept a drive alive that resulted in a touchdown for the Broncos. It should have been offensive PI if anything, if the same standard that was used all year on Gronkowski had been used; it sure as heck was not PI on Ryan.

Offensive holding was called on the Patriots on their first possession of the game; not once the entire game was it called on Denver, which strains credulity. That penalty killed our first drive.

Several times PI should have been called on Denver but was not; if any one of the multiple instances where the infraction happened near the end zone had been called, it would have been the difference in the game.

I think if I were Roger Goodell and I knew that I had already been responsible for one game this year in which multiple national sports commentators accused the officials of determining the outcome of the game, and I wanted to make sure Brady didn't beat me and get to the Super Bowl, I might lean on the side of making it less obvious rather than more. More obvious is to openly take away everything the Patriots do, as in the regular-season game in Denver; less obvious is to call a handful of mostly-meaningless penalties against the Broncos after the game has already been determined, while refusing in multiple critical moments to call penalties that the Broncos commit that, if called, would give the Patriots too much hope of winning.

Remember that it was not Hochuli and company who gave the Patriots the ball on the screen pass fumble - they called it a forward pass.

But really all you need to look at to know this game was not officiated above-board is the Amendola play. Anyone who is not legally blind can see his knee is down, and the ball is far more in control, when his knee touches the ground, than the ball was in the supposed catch Martavis Bryant made in the end zone that allowed the Broncos to play at home in the second round rather than in Cincinnati; and yet neither Simms nor Nance said a word about it, and the officials pretended his knee didn't touch.
 
A lot of hand stuff went uncalled on both sides downfield but both reviews that went to 345 Park came out in the Pats favor, so not much to complain about here.

In fact, I thought that Gronk's catch at the 10 or so in the closing moments of the game before the Pats scored actually came out of his hand and touched the ground before he had complete control of it...I was yelling to my kids that they should "snap it fast, snap it fast." I was amazed that the awful announcers didn't start to make a big deal out of it to try to influence the people in New York since they were inside the two minute warning, but at that point things were moving very fast and everyone was taken up in the drama.
 
But really all you need to look at to know this game was not officiated above-board is the Amendola play. Anyone who is not legally blind can see his knee is down, and the ball is far more in control, when his knee touches the ground, than the ball was in the supposed catch Martavis Bryant made in the end zone that allowed the Broncos to play at home in the second round rather than in Cincinnati; and yet neither Simms nor Nance said a word about it, and the officials pretended his knee didn't touch.

His knee touching before the ball came out is completely irrelevant. Amendola had not secured the ball before contact was made (I don't think even the most homertastic NE fan would argue that). Since (a) he did not have pre-contact control and (b) he was taken to the ground, the "receiver must maintain control of the ball even after hitting the ground" rule applies. As the ball came out almost immediately after hitting the ground, it's not a catch and not even close.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


MORSE: Patriots QB Drake Maye Analysis and What to Expect in Round 2 and 3
Five Patriots/NFL Thoughts Following Night One of the 2024 NFL Draft
Friday Patriots Notebook 4/26: News and Notes
TRANSCRIPT: Patriots QB Drake Maye Conference Call
Patriots Now Have to Get to Work After Taking Maye
TRANSCRIPT: Eliot Wolf and Jerod Mayo After Patriots Take Drake Maye
Thursday Patriots Notebook 4/25: News and Notes
Patriots Kraft ‘Involved’ In Decision Making?  Zolak Says That’s Not the Case
MORSE: Final First Round Patriots Mock Draft
Slow Starts: Stark Contrast as Patriots Ponder Which Top QB To Draft
Back
Top