- Joined
- Dec 18, 2004
- Messages
- 12,756
- Reaction score
- 22,826
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.100% agree with that rationale. More so just see the camera along the goal line as being something that should be a given. While it wouldn’t solve the more murky situations, it would provide more clarity on replays than there currently is. It’s so ridiculous when the telecast shows what the officials see, and it’s some asinine diagonal shots that offer nothing.I agree, but I wonder how often it would actually work right. Most of the time, if you can't tell very obviously that a ball crossed the goal line, it's because it's underneath a giant pile of bodies that would probably be blocking the view of that camera anyway.
How would the chip tell if the knee hits the ground or another player's shoulder pads or whatever?The NFL already has chips in the ball... be easy to add a sensor net to the inner bladder... they use it for the next gen stats
the nfl would need to put sensors on players though to make it work... need to be able to detect a knee or whatever hitting the ground, determining the relative proximity of the player at that time... be difficult on the player end... what happens if it shorts out...
That Damn Belichick... he cut our sensors off!!!?!!?!
Just spit balling here.... I would imagine that defensive players would have the same types of sensors that could measure impacts... So multiple data points would be created... If the knee hits the ground, only one would...How would the chip tell if the knee hits the ground or another player's shoulder pads or whatever?
I'll leave the last word to scientists or engineers, but as far as I know the technology exists for satellites, hundreds of miles above the earth, to penetrate dense jungle canopies and thick cloud cover. A US football field is 160 feet wide. I'm pretty sure they can develop a device to be placed in each pylon that can distinguish a football from and through other objects 80 or 90 feet away.I agree, but I wonder how often it would actually work right. Most of the time, if you can't tell very obviously that a ball crossed the goal line, it's because it's underneath a giant pile of bodies that would probably be blocking the view of that camera anyway.
What they need is some kind of chip technology that reads whether the ball crosses the line, but the weird shape of the ball probably makes that difficult too. You'd need a chip basically inserted into every outer most point on the oblong.
jets dont need oneI’m still baffled the NFL doesn’t have a camera pointed across the goal line of every single fuking game
jets dont need one