PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans
  • NEWS ▼
  • FORUM ▼
  • SCHEDULE
  • NFL ▼
  • STATS ▼
  • GAMES ▼
LOGIN | REGISTER
PatsFans.com › Patriots Blog › Derek Havens › Butler's Punishment Could be More Detrimental than Cons...
Derek Havens

Butler's Punishment Could be More Detrimental than Constructive

Derek Havens
Derek Havens Staff Writer
June 11, 2015  · 9:00 am | 2 min read | @PatriotsHaven
Follow PatsFans.com
Google News ✉ Newsletter

Super Bowl XLIX hero, Patriots cornerback Malcolm Butler, has been absent from the Organized Team Activities to this point and now we have more details on the situation.

Jeff Howe of the Boston Herald reported Wednesday afternoon the second-year defensive back showed up late to the first practice and has been held off the field ever since.

Reportedly, Butler scheduled a flight to Boston the day before OTAs began and his flight was delayed due to weather conditions. When he arrived to the facility the next day, he was late for the start and head coach Bill Belichick decided to keep him off the field for the last three weeks.

Howe added while Butler has been held out of workouts on the field, he's been at the team meetings, film and weight training sessions.

Butler is expected to be back on the field soon, possibly as soon as Thursday when OTAs resume for June 11-12. The Patriots will hold Mandatory mini-camp on June 16-18.

While Howe gave us more clarity on a murky situation, there's still a question if there's more to the story. Based on the given information, however, this punishment seems very excessive and could ultimately prove to be more detrimental to Butler's development.

One line of thinking is Belichick could be trying to bring Butler back down to earth, after a busy off-season filled with public appearances and autograph signings born from his Super Bowl heroics.

But is this the right way to go about it?

It's hard to question one of the greatest coaches in NFL history, but that doesn't mean every move is the correct. By keeping Butler off the field for three weeks, he's lost mental reps as he goes into his second year.

Given the cornerback (lack of) depth, Butler is penciled in as a potential starter. While showing up late to work is wrong, these OTA workouts are voluntary and weather is out of Butler's control. I guess it's easy to make excuses with hindsight 20/20, but this seems over the top, even for Belichick.

While each NFL season is a marathon and the team is just beginning this year's journey, we'll have to play the wait-and-see approach over the next few weeks and into training camp to see if there's any ramifications from this incident. Hopefully Butler learns from this and can give himself more wiggle room moving forward.

Do you have a Twitter account? Follow me: @PatriotsHaven

This is an archived article originally published on June 11, 2015. Content reflects the editorial context of its original publication date.

More News Headlines:

TRANSCRIPT: Mike Vrabel Press Conference 8/15

TRANSCRIPT: Mike Vrabel Press Conference 8/15

By: Ian Logue
Here's the full transcript of what New England Patriots head coach Mike Vrabel had to say during his press conference on Saturday, August 15, 2026.
8 hours ago
MORSE: Good, Bad, and Ugly From Patriots’ Underwhelming Performance vs Colts

MORSE: Good, Bad, and Ugly From Patriots’ Underwhelming Performance vs Colts

By: Mark Morse
Breaking down the Patriots' underwhelming preseason tie vs. Colts, this report covers the good, bad, and ugly, plus Christian Gonzalez's contract demands.
15 hours ago
Friday Patriots Notebook 8/14: Receiver Battle is Getting Interesting

Friday Patriots Notebook 8/14: Receiver Battle is Getting Interesting

By: Ian Logue
Analyzing the Patriots' 13-13 tie, the receiver battle heats up as Kyle Williams shines, no targets for Kayshon Boutte and Andy Borregales misses 3 FGs.
1 day ago
Patriots vs. Colts Quick Reactions: An Undisciplined Performance

Patriots vs. Colts Quick Reactions: An Undisciplined Performance

By: Ian Logue
Reviewing the Patriots' 13-13 tie vs. Colts, penalties marred sharp play from DeVito and surprising Jam Miller, with kicker Borregales struggling.
2 days ago
Vrabel on Gonzalez’s Absence: CB is “Physically Unavailable”

Vrabel on Gonzalez’s Absence: CB is “Physically Unavailable”

By: Ian Logue
Addressing Christian Gonzalez's absence, Vrabel confirms the cornerback is 'physically unavailable' for practice, adding to contract frustrations.
2 days ago

📈 Recent Most-Read Articles:
1
2022 New England Patriots Draft Picks – Full List
2
2024 Patriots Draft Picks – FULL LIST
3
Patriots Announce Ticket Increase, Dropping Stadium Parking Fees
4
Tom Brady’s ‘Life Is Hard’ Speech: Full Patriots HOF Transcript
5
Heading Into Free Agency, Patriots Have Two Tough Player Decisions to Make

📅 This Week in Patriots History:

From our archive - this week all-time:
July 31 - August 15 (Through 26yrs)

  • Patriots Malcolm Mitchell Suffers Arm Injury vs Saints(2016)
  • Glenn's Suspension Inevitable?(2001)
  • New England Patriots Training Camp Day 4 Observations(2016)
  • 10 Years Later, Gillette Stadium Still a Great Venue(2012)
  • Torry Holt the Odd Man Out?(2010)
  • MORSE: What to Look For in Patriots Preseason Game #1(2024)
FULL ARCHIVE
Free Newsletter

BE THE FIRST TO KNOW

Join 2,000+ fans getting exclusive stats, analysis, and insights delivered straight to their inbox every week. Never miss a play.

📊
Weekly Stats Deep-dive analysis
🎯
First Access New features & tools
📤
Breaking News Player Signings & Rumors

Subscribe Now

* required

Intuit Mailchimp

PatsFans.com Social Logo
PATSFANS.com

The longest-running independent New England Patriots site online since 2000. Not affiliated w/any school, team or league.

Resources

  • Patriots Forum
  • Schedule
  • Patriots Roster
  • Transcripts
  • Patriots Wiki Pages
  • Archive

Stats

  • Offensive Stats
  • Opponent Stats
  • Offensive Line
  • Snaps Overview
  • Penalties

Analysis

  • Snap Analysis
  • Personnel Groupings
  • Stats By Personnel
  • Top 10 Plays
  • Offensive Line
  • Defensive Totals

Site

  • About Us
  • Podcast
  • Newsletter
  • Contact Us

© 2000-2026 PatsFans.com

Privacy Policy Editorial & Reporting Advertise RSS Feed