- Joined
- Aug 12, 2005
- Messages
- 3,920
- Reaction score
- 499
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.Pre emptive apologies here but I wonder if somebody can tell me what the penalty was on the first play of the Superbowl. Seems it should have not
been called a safety because penalty.
I couldn't find anything relating to this in forum.
Then what did you think the proper call was?
It was illegal motion. The entire Broncos team was set except for Manning himself who was walking forward to bark out signals when the ball was snapped.Pre emptive apologies here but I wonder if somebody can tell me what the penalty was on the first play of the Superbowl. Seems it should have not
been called a safety because penalty.
I couldn't find anything relating to this in forum.
When I saw that flag sail, I thought for certain they were going to bail Manning out. I was shocked it went against the Donks.
They tried their best to help the Donks out on Pete's first challenge. The reply clearly showed the ball landed either at the first down marker or within inches; and instead of moving the ball to where it should've been placed, Pete lost the challenge and the ball was kept a full yard short of the marker.
It was illegal motion. The entire Broncos team was set except for Manning himself who was walking forward to bark out signals when the ball was snapped.
Sure the Seahawks could have accepted the penalty but I think getting a safety is better than giving the ball back to Denver, 1st and 15. Anyone who thinks that the Seahawks wouldn't have the choice to accept or decline is thinking of a false start. A false start is a pre-snap penalty so the play doesn't count. Illegal motion is a penalty that occurs at the snap, so the play counts.
The rule is that you can only challenge the spot of the ball if a 1st down is at stake. The NFL doesn't want coaches challenging saying it should be 4th and 5 instead of 4th and 6 (although I doubt many coaches would challenge the spot of the ball unless a 1st down was at stake).Yeah that stood out to me as well, but could that have been a mistake on Pete's part?
Don't coaches usually challenge the spot? Not sure what the rule is, but I think I remember the refs saying he was challenging that it was a first down. I'm not sure if in that situation, they are still supposed to review the spot and adjust.
When I saw that flag sail, I thought for certain they were going to bail Manning out. I was shocked it went against the Donks.
I saw the replay today. The call was "illegal motion...on #18...that penalty is declined."